Reviews for San Matteo Takeaway in New York, NY
4 small slices for 19 is insane
Pizza was 20 minutes late. Gave as late pizza and cold chicken parmesan. That got to sit in the tin for a half hour. Lied about... how long it would take then says "I can't do nothing you prepaid" Read more
Love this place.. aunthentic Italian ingredients make some of the best pizza around. The creamy burrata had me thinking I was... back in Rome. Not your regular corner pizzeria.. definitely a notch above. Read more
Food: 5 Value: 5 Atmosphere: 3 Customer Service: 5 Avg: 4.5 Notes: burrata was creamy deliciousness. Arugula was so bitter. Has... a B health rating which was kinda gross. But the food looked v good. I was very satisfied by the amount of burrata they gave Read more
We used to order Il Salumaio at least twice a month! Soooo enjoyed the great quality at affordable prices, but since reopening... not only our favorites are not part of the menu (gnocchi fromagi or pasta al formo!) but prices are too high for pasta, and nobread included anymore!. No sandwiches available either! And if pizza was what we liked, we could order to San Mateo directly(same family). Disappointed ???? Read more
There are few things better in life than alfresco dining on a hot summer night, especially when the wine is flowing. Il Salumaio... holds it's own on a street jam packed with quality restaurants. If you're looking to indulge in a bottle of reasonably pricedwine (or several) in an authentically causal Italian haunt, this is the place for you. The cold antipasti is superb, but don'tbe shy to order something more hearty -- especially the Parmigiana Melanzane (Eggplant Parm) served with a well balanced redsauce that is perfectly salty and sweet. Read more
I had the salads nicoise here and it was excellent! My boyfriend had the steak, which was cooked perfectly, and the vegetables... were heavily seasoned and delicious. We had apps, drinks, dinner, Read more
Great place for takeout, the pizza was delicious!