Reviews for San Matteo Pizzeria e Cucina in New York, NY
We walked in here one night and had a great dinner. We split an appetizer and each got a pasta, which was the right amount of... food. I also love places that still give you a bread basket, and this was one of them! Read more
Best pizza place, and not only pizza… Beautiful Italian heart and soul ?? Very welcoming atmosphere, delicious food and very... professional people working there! Definitely recommended! Don’t remember name of this desert but it’s something out ofmind) my fiancé said he eat the best burger in his life that night) Read more
I tried 2 pizzas, de Luca, prosciutto and mozzarella and tiramisù + espresso. The pizza dough was good, light and soft.... Ingredients were fresh and flavorful. About the tiramisù, for my opinion, I would have preferred a few more "savoiardi" andless "panna". Real Italian espresso. I recommend to try at least once!!! Read more
Ordered two margheritas through postmates. Top photo is the regular magherita and the bottom is the Regina magherita. Tasted... like normal thin crust pizza. I expected more basil on both pizzas. We only got two leaves for both pizzas and they weren’teven fresh as advertised. I’m not sure why it has so many high ratings. It may be better in person and with the service? Read more
Nice place, but pizza quality could be improved. It is funny that the waiters pretend to be Italian by saying stereotypical... things (mamma Mia! Signore! LOL). Maybe I will go back to try non-pizza things, I have no idea about their quality We had 2pizzas and one panuozzo dessert with ice cream and we paid around ~70$ (no drinks) Read more
We went there on a Saturday evening. Very nice staff, delicious pizzas ! A family place obviously, which was nice. The tiramisu... is homemade, no doubt, and really good. Nutella pizza for those who are not afraid ! Read more
Love the servers here, super friendly and informative. Ordered a pizza and two pasta dishes everything was flavorful and... presented well. Had an amazing truffle pasta the last time I was here, unfortunately it’s out of season rn. But I will becoming back for it again! Read more
Food and ambience were good. My husband had the ravioli pasta special and it was amazing. I had the Paccheri alla Matriciana... pasta and it was okay. Nothing special. We also got the Fritto Misto (calamari) to share and it was really good! The waitresswas Italian. Protip: do not ask for ranch for your pizza. My friend did this and the waitress almost had a heart attack. Read more