Reviews for Sagaponack NYC in New York, NY
Delightful dinner, the fluke tartare was a masterpiece, perfectly balanced! Loved the bay scallops with mushroom and peas as... well as most of the other dishes. Definitely recommended! We’ll be back Read more
We ordered the very well priced tasting menu, which was amazing!!!!!! Great atmosphere and the service was phenomenal, in... addition to the tasting menu we ordered the chicken skewer a la cart and that was fantastic. Must return to tryout otherdishes! PS, if you order the risotto, 10% from that sale goes to World Central Kitchen which is a great cost! Read more
It's a great place to hang out with friends. All dishes that we ordered, from small bites to large plats, are all shareable.... Each dish's presentation is on point, and the attention to detail is appreciated. No dish tastes too heavy or under-seasoning.Some plates took time to prep because these are ordered to make. Read more
I went on a Wednesday after work for drinks and oysters. Everything was great. The service was attentive. The bartender was... amazing (drinks were on point) and the oysters are so yummy. I honestly didn't want to go home. It was just a relaxing, comfortable good time. Read more
Phenomenal seafood spot in flatiron and true neighborhood gem!! Offers a la carte and tasting menu choices. EVERYTHING on the... menu was delicious! Hard to pick a favorite dish. Salmon and fluke apps were up there as were the cavatelli, risotto, andBrussels sprouts. Good service, good drinks, and good ambiance. Left immensely satisfied and look forward to returningsoon! Sagoponack is definitely flying under the radar right now, but you will be delighted if you go! Read more
Excellent spot. Not pretentious, great food quality and friendly staff. Fluke Crudo was a dish to remember, and the Thai Milk... Tea provided an excellent finish to the evening. Everything was cooked perfectly and not needlessly over-seasoned; natural freshseafood flavors were able to shine through. Great for a casual date, would absolutely return. Read more
Every single meal I’ve had here has been an absolutely delightful experience. The service staff is friendly and... skillful—anticipating my needs while exceeding what one expects of an elevated neighborhood restaurant. The food has beenexceptional since they’ve reopened during the pandemic, with the menu going through refinements with each season. The wineselection and curation has been *chef’s kiss* each time, and the cocktails are inventive (and also like superdelicious). Generally spacious and during the pandemic’s peaks, they were able to adhere to social distancing very well.Great for events, too, as they have a second floor that overlooks the bar. The oysters come beautifully dressed but if you’relooking for that perfect IG story, look no further than the fluke tartare. If you’re not feeling seafood vibes, the kabochacurry’s a really solid option as well. Seriously impressive, especially considering that they rebranded during the pandemicand have been able to continuously improve since then. Props to the team! Read more
Had a great time here, the ambience, food, and service were all great. The R-squared seasonal cocktail was so good and not too... strong, tasted just like fall. The Parmesan fries were delicious and the accompanying aioli was great too. We ordered the steakto be medium and it was cooked perfectly. The sauce and side of potatoes also tasted so good, overall an amazing entree. I alsoenjoyed the Thai Milk Cake dessert, not too sweet. Overall I think the side, big entree, and dessert were enough food for ourparty of 2. Throughout the night I found that the waitstaff was very attentive and they were able to accommodate for myallergens. Would love to come back here someday just to hang out at the bar! Definitely recommend. Read more