Reviews for Potbelly in New York, NY
I think I got the pepperoni melt it was good would get it again
An amazing sandwich shop with great choices of pre selected sandwiches and the option of building your own from scratch. You can... choose 3 different sizes. The staff prepare your sandwich in front of you and are very generous with the fillings. There'splenty of indoor seating too. Read more
Made me really sick , doesn't recommend told that frank Ocean looking guy not to add to much pepper to my sandwich and he didn't... listen. They are bad wit instructions and food had no flavor nor the mayo taste like it was home made smh not coming back. Iwant all my refunds. Also found it funny every time guy would put peppers on my sandwich they would joke about it sendingpeople to the rest room seems like foul play ???????? Read more
My go to on lunch on Friday love their sandwich so delicious
I love Potbellys ! Ample menu choices but I love the WRECK personally Friendly customer service Conveniently located Love that... this location closes at 8 PM compared to the Maiden Lane location that closes at 3 PM. Read more
They?re located at 90 Broad Street G103, Financial District in Lower Manhattan, New York, NY. I placed an online order and... delivery was quick since they?re right downstairs from us. They have always given great service and delicious subs, not tomention their milkshakes and cookies. Read more
Came here for lunch. An average experience overall. Tried the chicken tomato mozz because Potbelly was marketing it... everywhere.....disappointed...very bland, no flavor and dry...vinegar added some flavor but not enough..maybe try add some typeof sauce to this samdwich... also no fountain drinks..only bottled drinks... average experience Read more
I'm normally a fan of Potbelly's unfussy soups and sandwiches, but I am a bit disappointed with the service at this location.... I've ordered to-go online a few times and try to schedule it in advance based on my schedule. Every time I come, my order isdelayed. I've waited upwards of 35 minutes for a soup/sandwich combo, resulting in a cold soup and stiff sandwich. It would bemore understandable if I only just placed the order, but it defeats the purpose of ordering ahead if I'm still going to wait 20+minutes for lunch. Read more