Reviews for Pizza and Shakes in New York, NY
Looking to combine fun and vibrant eats? Check out Carnegie Diner?s sister-store Pizza & Shakes. All their pizzas come in one... unique size and one price featuring a variety of chef's specialty pizzas as well as a build-your-own option. Unlimited toppingson your personal pizzas now that?s what I?m talking about! Their Premium milkshakes include the basic flavors but their uniquegelato flavors is a must try. Read more
Outstanding!!!!! French-bread style pizza in a Subway-sandwich type creation process. Either choose one of the menu items or... make your own. Buffalo Bill is phenomenal! Fresh cheese and sauce, perfect toppings, love it love it love it. Are youreading this? You MUST stop here! 10/10. I will be back! Read more
Great spot to grab some pizza if you're in the midtown area by the westside (West 57th Street). The pizza "gimmick" is somewhat... reminiscent of the " &Pizza" franchise with the addition of their dessert area. Overall, I had a delicious meal there. Can'tcomplain one bit. You have to try it at least once..Its good stuff ???????? Read more
Walked by hungry and left happy. It's an American version of Neapolitan pizza. You can order a favorite or create your own,... there are enough toppings and sauces to customize it! There were 20 plus flavors of Gelato to choose from. We had the Greekcherry gelato. I would definitely eat here again! Read more
I got one Columbus Circle pizza on a Friday around 5pm. The service was quick and the restaurant was fairly clean. The pizza was... a bit too heavy on the cheese which made the slices fall apart. Other than that, it was very tasty. Read more
Great Pizza I built myself a meat lovers with red sauce and pesto wife had the overload. Also great shakes first place with... Gelato shakes was very good and wife had scoop of Gelato. Customer service was great from the whole staff. Highly recommend. Read more
Walked by a few times gong to Nordstrom?s?my son wanted lunch and I tempted him with a shake. The place did not disappoint. The... pizza was just big enough for the two of us and the shakes were delicious. The pizza was fresh and came out quick. We orderedpepperoni and extra cheese. the cheese was delicious- not processed as is the pepperoni. My son said the crust was his favoritepart! Very reasonably priced also. They also have several gelato flavors and cool toppings. They have homemade ice cream barstoo. There are not any tables but stools and a counter to eat. I would definitely return!! Read more
Honestly, I passed Pizza & Shakes many times before walking to the subway, and the bright and colorful exterior always felt so... inviting. So on this cold Fall day, I decided to pop in the store to grab a snack to wait out the busy rush hour to pass by. Iwas pleasantly delighted to see that the interior design matched the exterior with bright neon colors, an excitingInstagrammable wall, and an intuitive ordering system from far back you place the order and walk forwards to pay and then, youcan get gelato for dessert! As I was picking out, a super friendly staffmember named Ulysses helped me sort out what dish Iwanted to order, I ended up going with the Overloaded minus the Mango Habanero sauce. Let me cut to the chase, it was DELICIOUSand oh, so filling! The cheese and tomato base tasted fresh, the italian sausage & pepperoni with sliced mushrooms make for asublime mix on a thin crust pizza. Unfortunately, because of the cold weather, I opted out of grabbing gelato for dessert,though I promise i'll be back soon to try it out! Shoutout to Donna and Ulysses who were working the shift when I came in, theywere delightfully friendly, enthusiastic, and provided excellent service! Additionally, I LOVE the unique and creative design oftheir takeout boxes for the pizza! Read more