Reviews for Paul's on Times Square in New York, NY
This place has a small entrance door but the inside area has great sitting. It is so spacious and nice. They have the amazing... poster on wall, showing NYC prior to 2000. Margarita Pizza and drinks were good. Would not recommend Bruschetta as it was notthat great. Read more
I wish service had been better as I can’t really comment on the food. I was only able to order fried calamari as the bartender... did not ask if I wanted to order anything else. She was more focused on other tasks. I even had to ask for water and then itnever Got refilled. Also website promotes happy hour so ordered the calamari and still got charged full price instead of the$12. If looking for a spot near theatres there are much better Italian spots to go to Read more
Had dinner here on a Tuesday night. Ordered the chicken parmigian. Chicken was a bit rubbery and the pasta was way overcooked. ... Sauce was from a jar and bland. Got the cheesecake for dessert, was OK but could tell it wasn't made on site. Read more
Had caprese salad for an appetizer which was very tasty. Had a couple drinks from the bar which were also pretty decent. For... the main courses we had chicken parmesan and lobster ravioli. Both came to the table very hot and well presented. Read more
Lobster ravioli with vodka sauce was good. Mushroom pappardelle was bland. Also ordered the calamari which was the best part of... the meal. Bill ended up being $100 before tip, which is overpriced! Never saw the receipt, so unsure if that was correct. Read more
The food was good but not for the high prices. Everything was ala carte and Paul's didn't offer a children's menu. I know that's... fairly basic for New York but as someone who travels with children, a kids menu and clean bathrooms is a must and they didn'thave either. Read more
Food was delicious. Service was good and speedy. Atmosphere nice. I would go again
Great experience! Friendly staff! My daughter loved the pizza. We had delicious appetizers!