Reviews for Patsy's Pizzeria in New York, NY
The pizza had a nice flavor but it was delivered to me cold, which is strange considering this location is only an 8 minute walk... from my house. We had to reheat it in our own oven. The calamari was chewy and seemed like it was over cooked, as well. Read more
Quite possibly the best NYC pizza there is bar none. Wonderful coal flavor and amazing crust and cheese. The sauce has a clean... finish and the atmosphere is quite nice. HOWEVER, and this is BIG. There is no consistency. Sometimes the pizza is 9.5/10 andsometimes a solid 7. Would recommend sticking to dinner at the latter half of the week and weekends. Several times I?ve hadcrust not cooked all the way and toppings on one side of the pizza. Read more
Been meaning to come here for a while and now I wished I came sooner! This is the definition of a perfect New York slice and you... can?t get much better than this. It?s definitely work the trek from wherever you are! I?ll make a stop by anytime I?m in thearea again or any of the other locations. Read more
I love this place when I travel into New York we normally stop here to get some good pizza in the early hours .. but this time... we stopped in was during the week in the evening and we had to wait a pretty long time for the waiter to take our order . Myhusband was pretty upset because when he had enter the restaurant, he had told the waiter what he wanted and instead he saidI?ll come back to you . The waiter kept sitting people and then went to take an order of a family that had came after us . Wejust stopped in for pizza and some sodas to then keep driving out towards Maryland but instead we got stuck there for 2 hours .There was only one waiter . We waited for the sodas for some time & then also the pizza . Plus the pizza came burnt. Thepeople that came after us were served first . My husband said the service sucked, the waiter was slow and the restaurant needsmore help ? especially In the evenings when the place gets full ? will try next time to only visit this place early hours ?because the pizza is really good but not this time ? we had burn pizza ? Read more
The pizza is good I like thin crust. However I wish they spread the topping and have more options.
What is perfection? New York pizza should be so simple, it wouldn't pass an entrance test to a preschool. Basic thin crust, that... tears with the resistance you'd expect from a 7yo at bedtime, and yet soft enough to warrant the folding we know these slicescommand. A plentiful sauce, enough to constitute the majority flavour profile, piquant acid and with only natural tomatosweetness. The cheese is there only to create a texture contrast, and this cheese is in the perfect quantity to not dominate thewhole. It's $15 of New York pizza perfection. It sounds crazy, but it's hard to find a great slice among all the slices thatdominate the streets here. Patsy's is also in a wonderful neighbourhood. Catch the 6 up to 116th and enjoy a great walk topatsys. It's perfect new york slice pizza. Read more
I had a slice of cheese from the window. It's a very good slice but if you're visiting NYC and have limited time, the dirty... secret is that some of the $1 pizza places in midtown and downtown are pretty much just as good (not all though). The slice hereis NY style with a lot of flop and above average amount of cheese. Crust is toward the soft and chewy end. Read more
Came today for the second time. The pizza is crispy, thin, and not too filling, just the way my wife and I like it. The walls... are filled with photos of celebrities, politicians and the who's who of different walks of life. Today I was surprised by theGovernor being there. Read more