Reviews for P.J. Clarke's Lincoln Square in New York, NY
Great oysters, pot pie and cheese cake. Great New York classic with several locations, all just as good. Really good service, a... reservation always advisable and great food and beer. Read more
There’s a bit of an up charge for the historic ambience. My tiny Irish waitress informed that corned beef is a pain in the... neck to make so whatever they are doing here it must be working because the corned beef Reuben is 12/10 and keeps me comingback. The only reason I’m not giving them 5 stars is because we got seated next to an older man who coughed through our entiremeal. Read more
I had the Sweet Chili Wings and they were amazing! The Caesar salad appetizer is also very good. We ordered the Fish and Chips,... which was a solid choice. The four stars is bc the cocktails were only OK. Ordered the Queen's Gambit, the Palomo, and theNegroli. They were all very average, at best. The place is very cute and fun in a classic kind of way. They had a jukebox goingthat was on point. The food is A+, the atmosphere is A, the cocktails were a C+. Read more
Classic cocktails, fresh food in generous portions, and beautifully restored 19th-century interiors! This place was already... historic when the real Mad Men drank and dined here in the 60's. From floor to ceiling, every inch is packed with character andcharm. Some iconic establishments fill their walls with photographs of politicians and celebrities who visited over the years.Despite hosting some of the biggest names from around the world, this place chooses to fill its walls with photographs of thelegendary bartenders who've loyally served its customers for 160 years. Priorities! Spin some oldies on the juke box and fillyour belly at this hallmark of American culture. Read more
You can tell this is an emblematic spot in the city. The food was really good. Drinks were fire. Had a great time
Great food. To spend evening. Friendly and kindly personnel, Classic large space. Bar space for drinks to take inside. Sound of... music from a jukebox. In a old fashion atmosphere. Restaurant for all ages. Try the Special recipes of fries. Burgers, Salads. Read more
Absolutely loved P.J. Clarke's 100% recommend it for anybody coming into New York for vacation and even some locals who may have... never given it a shot. Let's first start off with the service, the service was amazing! Our waitress was on point. She kept upwith all of our oyster needs and drinks as well she didn't miss a beat! Nextly the food. Where to begin when talking about thefood? Let's start with the appetizers we got the delicious deluxe appiters which was half a lobster, 6 east coast oysters, 6littleneck claims, and 6 bloodspot claims and four jumbo shrimp along with a dozen of oysters. Everything tasted amazing and weended up with four dozens of oysters that had two types of oysters served, I don't know the species sadly, but they weredelicious. Nextly I ordered the 8 Oz. Filet mignon medium rare. Let me say they didn't add any unnecessary flavoring simply pitsea salt on the steak and cooked it and wow was the flavor amazing the meat almost melted in your mouth. I also ordered trufflefries and baked macaroni and cheese. The truffle fries were delicious and really caught me off guard with the flavor profile ofsimple French fries. The macaroni and cheese really tripped me out being from Kentucky I never had peas in my Mac and cheese andhonestly I wasn't expecting how well it went together. Lastly and probably the best part of the night was meeting the managerafter dinner his name was Mazin Manahi, he took time out of his day to talk with us and get to know us. We really appreciatedhis time to talk with us and really made the trip personal and look forward to coming and seeing our new friend again! Read more
Not only was the food delicious, but the service was great! And the consideration given to my party, considering half of them... were late; was very much appreciated. Mazin took my reservation, welcomed us; and made us feel life regulars from the moment wewalked in. I’ll be back first chance I get! Read more