Reviews for NY Pizza Suprema in New York, NY
I was looking for a decent pizza place as there are so many in New York and this had many good reviews, so chose this place. I... also liked that this was family owned, so it's nice to support local businesses and family. There were so many options youcould choose from and the slices are big (compared to the UK, one slice here is about two slices in the UK). You queue up andpick if your type of pizza on offer, whether by slices, half a pizza or full pizza. You then choose if you want a drink whenpaying up, they take cash, contactless and card. You then wait for your pizzas to be reheated, but you can ask for them toremain cold. Despite having the queue, it went quite quickly. Ordering and paying was easy enough. Staff were nice andefficient! I got two Meat pizza slices and a large coke cola for $15, which was enough to fill me up! We sat inside, quite agood amount of space and lovely atmosphere. So worth visiting here for a reasonably priced pizza dinner! Read more
This is a typical New York style pizza place except that the prices are a bit steep in my opinion. Yes it is thin crust; crispy... and chewy crust with decent texture. Also just the right amount of sweet tomato sauce and cheese. I don?t think we can call thisone the best but it represents New York style pizza properly. When I was growing up in New York there were many joints with thisquality of pizza. This place gets crowded due to its high reviews and history. There are some tables in the back for smallgroups and condiments for pizza opposite the cashier table. Read more
Best pizza I have eaten in my life. New York street pizza. Large cuts, thin crust, served piping hot because it is reheated in... the oven. Offers a huge array of variety and flavours. Relatively cheap pricing for new york city compared to those offeringmore than just the basic flavour. BBQ chicken was amazing. Read more
Amazing pizza. Great taste. It's very difficult to find many varieties of vegan food or vegan pizza in NYC but here we had the... best pizza till now we had ever. Please try to have it whenever you come to Times square. Read more
I'm finally trying a NY style pizza and this place had lots of pics so off we went! It's near Madison Square Garden with seats... on the inside. We had to wait in line outside, but it moved quickly. I suggest you look at the menu outside because once youenter you're already being asked what you want so they can throw it on a pizza tray to heat up. I had the meat lovers andspinach dip. My choices were a little upscale so I paid $7 each including tax. No change to worry about here! And the sliceswere large enough to do the NY fold! Read more
This pizza store such big & one of the good quality pizza store in the city. employee behave so friendly and food also fresh if... you order full pie. Slice is not a good idea such as a Sicilian Slice because it?s not good sale but chess pizza slice best. Orwhole pie sure best idea to order. Read more
We ordered spinach dip, fig, meat lover and Sicilian sausage (thick crust). The flavors were very good, and the fig flavor... really stood out. If you like bacon-wrapped-dates type of flavor, the sweet-savory fig might be a good fit for you. The crustwas okay, but we would prefer more texture. The staff was not friendly and always in a rush. Overall, a good place to quicklygrab some food before taking trains! Read more
Delicious pizza, tasty! Lots of various pizza also for vegans, vegetarians. It was a long queue but it went fast. Only minor... problem is you need to say your pizza options 3 times. There is a restroom facility as well. Worth to try! Read more