Reviews for Mermaid Oyster Bar in New York, NY
First time here, amazing. We had a reservation and the wait was longer than expected so they brought us complimentary drinks.... The appetizers came out very fast. We got 9 oysters, the lobster, and the kale salad. All delicious. For entrees we got thetuna, pasta, and tacos. Again, delicious. Loved the mouse at the end as well. The waiter and staff were all so lovely and veryattentive! Read more
4.3/5 Good ambiance and food! We arrived earlier than our reservation so they sat us at the bar, which was perfect. We ordered... the Lobster Fritters, Littleneck Clams, Old Bay Fries, Grilled Octopus Salad, and the Wedge Salad. Our favourite was thegrilled octopus as it was very flavourful and cooked perfectly. We’d order this again. Yum! The other dishes were nothingspecial. The fritters didn’t taste much like lobster and were a bit doughy. The clams, fries, and wedge salad were what youwould find anywhere else. The service was good and it was a cozy place to hang out. We’d return to try some of their otherdishes! Read more
Devoured every bite, it was all delicious. I forgot to take pictures of the oysters and sea bass which were just as good. The... chocolate puddings were complementary which was so sweet! We'll definitely be back again. Read more
They have the best fish tacos! I love this place, the atmosphere is perfect, service is nice and food is awesome. I have been... there a few times. Nothing that I have try is disappointing. Oysters are really good, drinks and steak as well. Read more
fantastic happy hour! oysters and tacos were delicious, the shishito peppers were big and probably my favorite i’ve gotten in... the city, & the clam chowder had a lot of clams which was great. the cocktails were wonderful as well, can’t beat that pricetoo! also loved that they gave us complimentary chocolate puddings at the end. can’t believe we waited this long to go, wewill definitely be back. Read more
Loved the food! I ordered a linguine & clams. I do prefer my linguine with some type of cream based sauce though, so I think... that’s the only thing missing. Other than that- loved my meal. The service was also good. FOR OUTDOOR RESERVATIONS- I wasfreaking freezing. I was quite literally shivering outside and those heat lamps did not a thing for me. Not even my warm drinkcould assuage my frigid body. :( Perhaps getting some stronger lambs for by peoples feet? Anyway I enjoyed my time! Thanks forhaving us. Read more
Delicious!!!! First time coming here and not only was staff professional, courteous and quick, my meal was 10/10. We ordered the... raw seafood tower (amazing) the lobster fritters went crazy, the truffle syrup was soooo different and tasty & last but notleast, our drinks were phenomenal. Our server Danielle was the best ???????? Will definitely be back and will definitelyrecommend to others. Read more
We were passing this restaurant and saw people having oysters. So we ended up having 2 dozens of oysters during happy... hour. Oysters were $1.50 each during happy hours, 4:30- 6:30pm every day. Also, complimentary chocolate pudding was great.Services are good as well. ???????? Read more