Reviews for Mary O's in New York, NY
I had my 60th birthday party at Mary O's. Mary was so accommodating to me and my guests! The food was simply scrumptious! The... Shepards Pie and Chicken Curry were world class! The ceasar salad was sooo good! Mary provided her famous Scones and my guestscould not say enough about how delicious they were. Definitely a must try!!! Read more
Just received my scones today. Not sure why it took a long time for me to get them but the wait was totally worth it. I toasted... the scones and used the butter and jam that was sent with them. It was the most delicious thing I?ve ever had in my life. Sowarm and comforting. It was such a treat. Read more
If you're going to New York and are anywhere near the East Village or Lower East Side, you have to go to Mary O's! I was... visiting with my mother and sister and we stumbled upon Mary's late on a Sunday night when the village was super quiet. Aclassic serendipitous New York moment. No google or maps, just saw the green neon sign beckoning us over! We needed a beveragebefore we turned in for the night, and got one of the best local experiences we've ever had in the city. We ended up stayingfor a few rounds, chatting and hanging out with Mary and her staff. It was wonderful! Mary's story is incredible (check her outon Humans of NY), and her tales of resilience and rallying the community during the pandemic was inspiring (around her homemadescones, no less!). Supporting local businesses, especially these days, is a no-brainer. So head over to Mary O's for greatambiance, drinks, bites and excellent conversation. We couldn't have had a better time! It was a highlight of the trip and Ican't wait to go back next year. Read more
If I could give six stars I would. Scones are AMAZING!!! Texture and taste by itself was perfect... adding on the butter and... jam made it heavenly. Only thing more heavenly than the scones was Mary herself - absolute angel of a human being - the nicest,sweetest, kindest person! Found out about Mary (as I think many others did as well) through Humans of New York. Bought thescones for the good luck, would've been okay if I never received them, but received such a delicious magical product we'll onlybe purchasing more (and definitely visiting to try her other food items when we're in NYC!) Highly recommend! Read more
Everything was perfect from the beginning to the end. Mary is a so nice person. We call at 9.15pm to know if it was possible to... come. She said that normally the kitchen close between 9.15/45 but if we could be their in the 30mn she will wait. And she did.We had a lovely dinner, food was excellent, fresh and homemade. They were also a group of Irish musician playing violin live,the ambiance was so pleasant like at home. And without asking for it, Mary offered us her amazing warm scones. Thanks foreverything. We definitively come back to visit you during our next trip in NY ! Read more
Just received the day before Thanksgiving our awaitted box of Irish scones. We loved the segment on ABC news about the struggles... during the pandemic and how the business model changed. Even.more uplifting was the mention of the individuallly handrawnedThank You card ! Pure genius!. (We Love it!!!) All arrived well packaged and we are ready to enjoy our Irish Thanksgivingbreakfast with the warmed up scones, Irish Butter and homemade jam while watching Macy's Thanksgiving parade. We hope to stop byat the pub on our next trip to New York City. Long life and prosperity to Mary O's! Read more
My wife and I were touched by Mary O's story on CBS news and had to add the bar to our NYC visit on our 25th wedding anniversary... trip from NorCal. It was Sunday, there was a 'closed/private party' sign, but it appeared it was ending. We entered anyway, andwhile the bar was serving, we were disappointed that the kitchen was closed, which also meant we couldn't get the Irish dinnerswe were hungry for, nor get one of her famous scones. We ordered drinks and told our story to the bartender. We moved to a hightop looking at Avenue A and took in the sights both outside and in. 5# bags of flour were stacked floor to ceiling on nearlyevery wall both in the bar area and further back in the dining area. A few moments later while we were talking about thepedestrian traffic, a dish with a raspberry jam topping a steaming buttered scone slid in front of us delivered by Mary herself!We were momentarily speechless, and couldn't begin to describe what that meant to us. That and the ensuing, easy conversationwith Mary was the 2nd emotional highlight of the trip. We'll be back for those dinners and a lot more of the best scones we'veever had. Read more
The menu on google says $8 drafts but beers are $11-12 so I suggest you update. All other bars in the neighborhood are $7-8.... Why?s your Guinness so special? Read more