Reviews for Mama's Pizzeria in New York, NY
The oldest running pizza place in Morningside Heights. It's family owned and the original mama herself is STILL alive! Huge... Sicilians and unique garlic knots/rolls will keep me coming for years. Read more
Ordered through grubhub and our order was over an hour late. It seems that the owner either doesnt know how to navigate grubhub... on his end or pretended he doesnt know. I asked for a discount or at least a refund to forfeit my pizzas- i cannot just waitaround pizzarias twidling my thumbs for an hour, but all he told us was to ask for a refund on grubhub or wait... terribleservice but pretty good pizza Read more
Stuff was kind to help cleaning the tables. Didn?t really expect that for this type of slice pizza place. Pizza was fresh and... good! Read more
Really good tasting pizza. The large pie is a deal and really delicious. I have made many returns to this parlor. I take out... but they have tables to eat out or in. Read more
Today was the best day of my life. I became a made man. I went into the pizzeria wearing my finest linens on this warm NYC day... only to have The Godfather of NYC pizza/greater New England area extend his hand of greatness prior to me receiving my pizza (Heremembered me from March). 10/10 recommend to anyone in the NYC area to meet the legend himself along with the staff. Read more
The pizza was ok, they didn?t have much Options for the afternoon I went. Just cheese pizza and the pepperoni ????. The person... over there was really very rude. But it?s ok May be it wasn?t his day. We may come back again for a second visit. The pizzaslice is really large. Read more
Accidentally came here on our way to Mama Too?s Pizzeria a few blocks away. Really glad we got to try them. Really delicious... Sicilian slice. Thick, crispy, buttery, and airy. That?s just the crust. It had the right about of cheese and sauce ratio. Wejust wished they used a thicker cut pepperoni so they can cup up when put in the oven. Mama's Pizzeria is a neighborhoodinstitution in the UWS. Still family-owned and operated! Read more
Excellent tasting pizzas both regular and Sicilian ! Pasta dishes are very good as well. A new thing they do is no phone calls?... Which I don?t like, it was helpful last time Speaking to the guy on the phone but the meals are very good and plentiful. Youwon?t go wrong! Read more