Reviews for Maggie's Place in New York, NY
Called in for a lunch time drink. We were met at the door by a lovely and friendly person, we then sat at the bar and the person... serving was welcoming and attentive. The music playing in the background was great and the larger was crisp and cold. Wouldhighly recommend! Read more
This place is a little underrated so I’m giving it 5 to help boost. For an NYC Irish pub it’s a bit more clean and... vibrant. The Guinness pours nice and cold and the food is quality. Read more
The vibe, appetizers, and service were amazing!! They played Irish pop music & it was so lovely! I loved the scotch egg - was my... first time having and this was honestly filling on its own, but I made room for an entree and dessert! My partner also loved thetruffle burrata and prosciutto board - delectable smell and taste. Unfortunately, the entrees and dessert fell flat for us both.Didn’t have enough flavor. Presentation was great but I’m more interested in how food tastes. Was fun to go for restaurantweek but I wouldn’t go back. Read more
Maggie’s is simply gorgeous all around. Treasure in Midtown. I work in the are and am always looking for new places to go... after work. Finally can say I found my “cheers”. Warm and inviting. The nachos were my favorite. Huge fish and chips andhard to believe that this is an Irish pub since the even the salads were innovative and tasty. I have already been backtwice. Great happy hour crowd and early dinner. Read more
Terrific Irish inspired pub. High quality food, almost gastro pub quality. Attentive and friendly service. Expertly poured... Guinness with a top consistent with the parish priest. Highly recommended. Read more
Simply amazing, elevated comfort food. The atmosphere is old world without being stale and the food and drink options are... positively excellent. The scotch egg and elote nachos are a must try!!! Read more
For a Black Friday, it was a nice, quiet spot out of the hustle and bustle. Atmosphere was quite festive for the holidays.... Traditional Irish fare did not disappoint. Crispy, flaky and light fish with chips and steaming hot, generously toppedShepherd's Pie hit the spot on a blustery day. Since there were only two parties in the establishment, service was exceptional -friendly, attentive and gracious. Although we did not partake, Maggie's features lots of draughts on tap! Highly recommend itwhen at Rockefeller Center. Read more
Love this place! People, atmosphere and food are all good. Been there since the 70's- It was recently updated but also kept the... charm. The 1974 is a great cocktail. Loved the pot pie. Was packed with chicken and great on a cold night. My son crushed theburger and we stole a bunch of his sweet potato fries. Has a cool bar scene but i enjoyed sitting down to eat. We come hereevery time we visit NYC! Read more