Reviews for John's of Times Square in New York, NY
Better than average place but honestly nothing impressive. Convenient that it?s right there in the Broadway district & they?re... open a lil later for those who come out after the evening show is over can still get some food. They keep their menu basic whichnormally is a good thing. My drink was pretty good as well. Service was pretty good as well. Ambience was nothing too notablebut like that it?s very open & spacious. Their brick oven is a nice touch as well. Read more
Swung by last minute before a show to try and get in another quick pizza place for our own version of a pizza tour and was so... glad they were able to seat us right away! Because it was our second favorite pizza of the trip! Definitely worth it! Got the 6slices cheese pizza since the smaller size was gluten free only, and it was great. The sauce was a little sweeter, and thebottom crust was thin and crispy with a little thicker crust at the end. Service was great! And super quick and attentive sincewe were in a hurry. And loved that they didn?t hate our guts for sharing a small pizza! Must try! Read more
This place is really good. We got seats very quickly and the food didn?t take very long either. The margherita pizza was really... good and so were the Buffalo wings but was quite pricey. $30 for a large pizza and $18 for wings. Overall a nice place to eatsome good pizza for an expensive price. Read more
Fabulous pizza place! So cool to walk around times square and then go to this awesome pizza place, just to walk in and it's... located in a former church. The building and the ceiling is gorgeous. Pizza was delicious. I had the gluten free margarita, thecrust is so good. One of my friends got a regular pepperoni, which was also delicious. Pizza is by the pie, no slices, thereforealways made fresh!! Read more
This pizza place was great. Not only does it have a beautiful location but the experience was nice too. Our server was very... friendly and efficient. The serving size of the salad was large and could definitely feed two people. The pizza was so good too.Very fresh ingredients and very flavorful. I would definitely go back for more. Read more
The food here was so yummy! I knew fried cheese would be delicious, but the marinara for dipping was over the top delicious. The... Margherita pizza was perfection. One small pizza was more than enough for two of us. The atmosphere was exactly what I'denvisioned a New York City pizzeria to be like. The fact that it was once a church was a cool little fact. The stained glassceiling was beautiful. I definitely recommend wandering a little off of Times Square, or before or after a Broadway show, andenjoy this gem. Read more
This is some crazy great pizza! The Italian sausage in it was fantastic. Great cheese and the sauce is perfect or really close.... Great service also which is hard to find in some places. Well be going back at least one more time on our trip here to NYC. Read more
As former Manhattan Knights, John's was a routine stop for many of our visitors visitors as they were taken in by the unique... Stained Glass Windows still visible on the inside. The Pizza is better than average and the Sandwiches are decent, and theAppetizers are better than average? such as the Fried Calamari which is tasty with a good was a good Gravy on the side. It isthe atmosphere and the good weight staff that really make this a worthwhile stop for visitors. Read more