Reviews for John's of Bleecker Street in New York, NY
Loved this establishment. Having had Detroit style, Chicago style and pizza from Italy. Really loved John's Pizzeria. While... there was a line up, they were quick and nothing says a good piece of pie more than when their original is delicious. From thesauce to all the ingredients, you can taste the difference in the use of fresh ingredients and herbs. The service was fast andthe pizza was served right out of the oven, crispy all over, crunchy and just delicious sauce and cheese over a thincrust. Would definitely come back. Such a gem. Read more
I've been to quite a few pizza joints (see some of my Google reviews), and John's of Bleecker St is undoubtedly within the top... five of my favorite places! The pizza is thin and crisp all the way through! The sauce is very bold, boasting a strong tomatotaste which compliments the correct amount of cheese on each slice! Literally the perfect pizza!! I only wish I had ordered morethan one pie! Read more
Pizza was great. Staff made a recommendation after my initial order and I really enjoyed it. I appreciated that availability of... salads and the red peppers on my mixed greens salad were the sweetest I?ve ever had, in a good way. However it was difficult toeat since the container was stuffed so full. I?d come back and recommend to others. Read more
Excellent Pizza, first one for me in NYC. I?ll let you know how the rest of my ventures go here but this one will certainly be... hard to beat. I prefer NY style pizza and this was one of the best I?ve ever had. Watch out for the toppings price. Definitelymore bang for your buck buying a large. I recommend adding garlic to whatever other toppings you like. Enjoy! Read more
The vibe is great, I really enjoyed the atmosphere. The staff is friendly and the service is good. There was a massive line to... get in, this place is incredibly popular and rated as one of the best pizza places in NYC. The food was good, the sausage dishwe had was full of flavor. The pizza on the other hand was slightly below expectations. The crust is good and the ingredientsare good. So it should be a good pizza, but we had a lot of toppings with the specialty pizza we ordered and as a result it wassoggy in the middle. I noticed that several tables that ordered pizza heavy on toppings also took to scraping it off to eatpizza. I would recommend sticking with a single topping if any. Had we done that this would have likely been a 5 starestablishment. I still liked it, and would come back to try a simpler pie. Read more
So the hype for this place is real, I was thoroughly impressed with the entire experience. We came for lunch and staff was quick... to tend to us. We had our pepperoni pie within 20 minutes of sitting down. The pizza itself was amazing, perfect blend of freshtomatoes sauce, a crispy and buttery crust topped with a cheese that didn?t make you feel like you were eating a stick ofbutter. Would definitely come back. Read more
It?s definitely a solid option, but just short of being worth waiting in an extended line for. The service was great throughout,... as everyone that we interacted with was very friendly and we didn?t wait too long for the actual food to come out (though we didwait 20+ minutes to actually enter). The Meatball Dish and Mozzarella Sticks were both hot/tasty and a perfect intro for themeal. The pie itself was solid, but just not the best I?ve had in town. The Cherry Peppers (Hot) topping were good, butdefinitely lacked any sort of heat. Having only the crushed red peppers to add spice was a little disappointing. Besides thatthough, the flavors were on point. Read more
Pretty good pizza. The best in New York? I don't think so. I got the "John's original", great taste but it could have been... crispier. I don't like that you have to get a full pizza especially because I was by myself. The garlic bread was amazing. Theservice was great and the food came very quickly. Awesome atmosphere. There was outdoor and indoor seating available but you mayhave to wait in line for a empty spot when it's busy. Read more