Reviews for Insomnia Cookies in New York, NY
Cookies are amazing really good raps mad taste better than crumble cookies my fave are the chocolate chip
We ordered online and instead of contacting us that they were out of one of the cookies we ordered they gave us the wrong... cookie. When we called about it the woman told us they were out and rudely rushed us off the phone. Last time I ordered fromInsomnia my order never arrived. Not thrilled with their service. Read more
Insomnia cookies smells like heaven. The chocolate chunk cookie is my favorite and it goes well with the chocolate ice cream.... One thing I do not like about this location is the fact that they almost never have the bite size chocolate chunk cookies. Whyoffer that on the menu if you never have it!? Read more
Insomnia cookies are a spot and hit the spot! Great staff and fresh cookies. They were attentive to us and got us the right... combo they needed despite being busy with deliveries. They acknowledged us right away and we?re fresh and tasty. Definitelyshould stop in if you need a late night dessert. ???? ???? Read more
Delicious cookies best enjoyed when they are hot & fresh. My favorite is the White Chocolate Macadamia cookie. Cookies here are... a bit pricey but worth it if you have a major sweet tooth and need a craving fix. The box of 6 is the perfect serving to get asample of all their best cookies. Service is quick and friendly. Just don?t get stuck behind a newbie that doesn?t know thecookie flavors or names. Read more
I'm on a mission to find the best cookies in NYC and I certainly got a lot closer with Insomnia cookies. They are definitely the... type of cookie I'm looking for: soft and chewy, full of flavor and an amazing variety. I'm a big fan of the late hours (for ussweet toothed ppl especially late at night when we convinced ourselves we wouldn't buy a bunch of sweets). Only down side isthey have a very particular delivery range which defeats the purpose to me. I am slightly beyond delivery range and luckily wasable to use Uber eats at this location but had that not been an option, I would not have gotten them bc I'm not walking aroundat 11pm to go get cookies. With the added fees of Uber eats, it was a bit disappointing especially because they pride themselveson being a late night spot that will brings cookies right to your door. So Insomnia cookies, please work on your deliveryoptions. Living in Hell's kitchen, I feel like it should have definitely been an option for me. If you are in delivery range, Ido recommend trying them. You also can have them "shipped" to you, but also defeats the purpose when you have a sudden cravingthat needs to be addressed asap. Read more
So who gets ice cream sandwiches at 1:15am ? This guy and his wife !!! I would give this establishment 10 stars if I could ! ... From the still warm fresh out of the oven cookies to the amazing counter person ! Carl you sir are an awesome addition to theInsomnia Cookies organization! It was such a pleasure being served by you, my wife and I will pay many visits to you ! Now backto the cookies and ice cream ! All I can say is WOW !!! If you?re ever on 79th and Amsterdam Ave Insomnia Cookies is a mustvisit ! If you live locally they deliver until 3am !!! This place is for sure Cookie Monster approved !!! Read more
11/18/22 Update: I received a refund for this order. I'm increasing my original 2 star rating to 4 since customer service was... very quick to resolve the issue! Original review: This... interesting looking 6-inch deluxe cookie cake arrived an hour late(usually $19, but ended up being $30 with delivery fee + tax + tip). Adding 2 stars because this was a hilarious ending to ourfestivities and it still tasted pretty good! Read more