Reviews for Hamilton Hall in New York, NY
Freshest Guinness in town along with being perfectly pulled. The food and ambiance are like a friendly neighborhood pub run by... your best friend. Go and enjoy, there's even live music ???? on the weekends. Read more
Really nice place, good food and cocktails are on point. S
Great food and drinks. Just had one of the best old fashioned here. But the highlight was having one of the best Shepard's piei... n NYC. Boy have I missed it Read more
I found this place on the Seated app and decided to check it out. Upon arriving the owner(?), Mickey, asked us if we wanted to... be seated by the bar where the game was playing or somewhere quiet. We elected somewhere quiet since we were not intosports. We ordered the Oysters, Shepherds Pie, and Sears Salmon. Mickey recommended the Coops Island and Great Gunn because weadvised we like big oyster. Mickey gave us an additional 2 oysters because he said the remaining GG and CI oysters weren't asbig (BIG PLUS!~). I would definitely recommend the Alpine Oysters (it's on the happy hour Mon-Fri 4-8). The Coops Island andGreat Gunns followed in taste respectively. I don't usually order Shepherds Pie but something about the old fashion allAmerican decor made me want to try it. It was very delicious, best one I've had (though I haven't had many). Only caveat was theportion wasn't super filling but the taste more than makes up for it. The Seared Salmon on the order hand looked hearty andtasted very yummy. Overall, great experience and I'm glad I tried them out :) Read more
Great negronis! 1 of my favorites. I had the new curry fries and its delicious. Live jazz, dj sets and music on week ends. ... Can't wait for their garden to open up when the weather gets warner soon. Read more
Fantastic addition to the neighborhood. Gavin and Chynna are always a killer team to get you anything you could need. And Tasha... makes a fantastic drink. Also I love having a local place with live music, especially after a year of listening throughheadphones. Glad to make this a regular spot. Read more
Awesome food with a laid back chill atmosphere. This restaurant / pub has a very relaxing vibe with a great selection of... cocktails. They also have an extensive menu to satisfy that late night cravings. I ordered their signature Hamilton burger, andits one of the best burgers I’ve had in NY. Order it and taste its righteousness. I also got the salmon with risotto that wascooked to perfection. Seriously, this place got everything you need when you pass by Broadway. Read more
Great salad, martinis, and service! Loved the cozy atmosphere