Reviews for Edgar's Cafe in New York, NY
Used to be my go-to spot for desserts but won?t come here anymore. The size of their cakes just becomes smaller and smaller.... This is what I got for 9 dollars. And when I politely complained to the waitress, the owner came and yelled at me and told meto leave. I was appalled by his terrible attitudes. I am still in shock. This is not the way you should run a restaurant. Read more
Cozy antique decor. Friendly service. Very good breakfast options. Highly recommend the avocado toast with poached egg. A tad... pricey. Read more
It makes me sad to put a ?bad review? on a business that has history to this city but I feel like it?s worth mentioning. Most... important: The owner is very rude. He is very rushed for customers to order. I was sitting with my friend and he started yellingat a customer for not ordering right away (the customer kept repeating that he was waiting for someone) the owner startedspeaking on the low disrespectfully. (The person?s Friend walked in right after, very awkward. Owner did not apologize) thismade our experience very uncomfortable. On the other hand: These place has great variety of desserts, their food menu alsolooks great. However, they do have very strict rules about each customer spending more than 5 dollars (which I sort ofunderstand, and there is barely anything worth less than 5 dollars anyway) as well as a ***No Laptop or tablet devicesallowed*** which is good to know before you go planning on getting work done. The staff was kind, but the owner?s energy mademe not want to come back here again. Read more
We?ve been coming here for 8 years and just love it. Great local neighborhood place that makes you feel like you took a short... trip to Italy for the day. The owner Benny has been so friendly to our family and watched my daughter grow up. They are veryfamily friendly here and accommodating to kids. Great for brunch or Dinner with all fresh ingredients and affordable prices. Weare gluten free and there are a ton of options here for GF including bread, pasta and deserts! Read more
Our favorite restaurant in the neighborhood by a mile. Everyone that works here is super warm and friendly and we feel at home.... Cute decor, delicious pastries, a slow, calm European vibe, and good wines. Great date spot! The veggie pizza is absolutelyamazing - must try! We see negative reviews here of folks thinking this is a coffee shop where you buy a coffee and sit forhours with a laptop. Guys, this is a restaurant, not your work from home alternative. Read more
Fabulous Cafe which is named for Edgar Allan Poe. Lovely, friendly staff. The interior is charming. The desserts are downright... evil! . If you need a chocolate fix, look no further. They are dog friendly. They brought my dog a water bowl while I enjoyed mylatte, which also looked like dessert... Read more
I was strolling through the city with a friend & came across edgars and it was close by, We decided to go in! Love the vibe,... super cute place. the blonde lady was super sweet and gave us the menus quickly and gave me time to decide on what I wanted, Iordered the carrot cake. it was literally amazing!! love this place, definitely wanna come again!! Read more
So cozy! The Edgar Allan Poe theme makes the experience that much more enjoyable. I really enjoyed breakfast here, a lot of... delicious options, and the pastries are pretty good. Also the hot chocolate I really enjoyed!! Definitely worth a stop if you'relooking for a quirky yet reliably delicious place for breakfast. Read more