Reviews for Connolly's in New York, NY
Warm, quiet and cozy restaurant with good food. We ordered the Irish Beef Stew, Chicken Pot Pie and burger and all very good.... The Connolly and Brooklyn beers were also good. Read more
We ended up going here twice because the vibe was super welcoming! Was happy to finally find my stout beer too! They have a... variety of food options. From finger food that you can nibble on to proper filling meals! We ordered crab cakes, the shrimppasta, chicken dumplings and two of their cocktails. Oh, and the cocktails are a must-try! Ask any of the servers, they're allfriendly and happy to help. P.S. This is also one of the places that's open till 1-2am! Read more
First experience in an American bar and of course it was an Irish bar. Decent Guinness, really enjoyable burger, very friendly... staff. Felt at ease and a thoroughly enjoyable start to NY trip. Read more
Great wee place to eat and drink and at a very reasonable price considering it's close location to 5th Ave. All the food that... was served to us was delicious. We sat outside in their shelter as it was a nice day, however if you prefer to sit inside thereare ample seats. The staff were polite, prompt and well presented. Great to see a proper Galway guy working in an Irish pub???????? Read more
Amazing atmosphere, amazing staff Guinness is so fresh and properly poured and let me say the fish and chips are some of the... best I've ever eaten. Will definitely be returning and definitely recommend checking them out! Read more
Very nice Irish bar style atmosphere. The variety of beers and drinks is very good, the place is very large with two floors to... enjoy with large groups of people. The attention is very good and fast, any questions that the diner makes are very attentivewhen responding. It is usually very crowded but you can always find a place (depending of course on the size of the group thatgoes) Read more
Fish and chips were great. The kitchen has what it takes to deliver a crispy and perfectly cooked oversized fish filet and a... good heap of fries. Slaw was nice but was lacking a punch. If you are in the afternoon hangry time, this is the place. Worthmentioning the efficient and friendly staff. Unexpectedly, the Guinness pour was not up to my standards but was close… headwas not just above the rim. Read more
Place is Fn great, had a bit to much fun. The bar staff was top notch and friendly. Awesome all around experience. Big thanks to... Conor and Mike. Read more