Reviews for Cheesy Pizza in New York, NY
sausage parm hero...insane!!! nice size. i cut it into quarters, was able to only eat 2, right away. sliced sausage,... cheese+light sauce...omg Read more
Horrible customer service over the phone. The woman who took my order got my apartment number confused. She refused to send me a... new order after. Would not order from here again. Better in person! Read more
Excellent pizza. Really tasty, authentic NYC italian pizza place on the UWS. Great food, nice people but a bit pricey. Overall,... recommended ???? Read more
Good place for pizza and other associated stuff (salad, calzones, garlic knots, etc.). Staff was friendly and helpful in... accommodating our order. Salads are of decent size and freshness. Read more
Ok. Shout out to Cheesy Pizza. Our 1st time in the city and at Cheesy Pizza. The pizza was great and the staff was a 5 star... staff. Lovely people. So kind. Pizza was tasty and well priced. Only 20 min across the Hudson from our hotel. Very accessible. Read more
Just like the name says cheesy pizza. I saw the name cheesy pizza and I really wanted to see how cheesy the pizza really was.... It really was very cheesy and great. I recommend this pizzeria. Their plain cheese pizza is amazing. I also had their vodkaslice and it was awesome. I was more than what I was expecting. I'll definitely be back soon. Thank you... Read more
Great stop for a slice. I favor this place over others as the pizza is fresh and you can tell it hasn?t been sitting out and... slices are large. Great customer service, very friendly. Will stop in again for a slice, soon. Read more
Great pizza, old school style. Staff was good. The decor is a bit dated and worn but it gets nostalgia points for me, brought... back memories of pizza joints I visited as a kid. Maybe that was the point. I'll take the great pizza with none of the nonsenseover some of these new places with lovely light fixtures and garbage pizza. You don't come here for the ambiance though. Ifyour hungry for pizza don't hesitate but maybe go somewhere else if you are going on a date or with a group as the seatingsituation is a bit dicey and not group friendly. Read more