Reviews for Casellula in New York, NY
The cheese pairing was something to write home about! Get the 6 cheese flight, let them select for you based on your wine or... drink selection. You won’t regret it! Read more
The cheese menu was overwhelming but I suspect you can't go wrong. We were pleased with the wine and charcuterie as well. The... location is good for a pre-theater bite. Read more
Loved my experience at Casellula! If you're like me and know nothing about cheese and wine, it's perfectly fine! The wonderful... staff at Casellula have got you! I rarely comment on the wait staff's performance because the vast majority just don't reallymake an impression on me but the people here were so lovely. The cheese flight was a delight. Honestly, I was just expecting abunch of different cheeses to try out and that's that. But no, their cheese flight came out with condiment or side pairings thatwere thoughtfully crafted. The cheeses themselves were delicious but the pairings that they presented really gave the cheeseanother dimension. Lovely place. I will definitely be back. Read more
I have NEVER had a bad experience here. It's great for date night, business meeting, a glass of wine and light bites after a... show or just having lunch/dinner solo. The cheese selection is amazing and is constantly rotating and at just $10 per cheeseselection, you can get a many or a few as you want. The wine selection is vast and delicious. The pig as$ sandwich, mac &cheese, goat cheese truffles and chocolate cake are some of my favorites. This last time our bartender was Anthony and he wasincredible. He talked us through wine selections and made really great suggestions. I cannot recommend this place enough. It'sa bit of a hole in the wall which I like but that means it can get a little crowded at times as seating is minimal inside.However, they do offer outdoor seating now so check that out if inside is a little busy! Read more
Was absolutely stunned by the gorgeous pairings we received after ordering the fromagère’s picks. The variety was... incredible—we had cheese from around the world in all different varieties that all came with genius complements. I’ve trulynever had anything quite like it even after traveling extensively through Europe. The wine list and other selections were alsoto die for. I will not hesitate to come back hungry, with friends! Read more
This place is phenomenal. I've been 3 tines. Every time I am amazed by the knowledge of the wait staff, the quality of the... cheese and the fantastic pairings they make with cheese such as applebutter, carrot puree, chocolate, chutney. All the pairingswork so well. The staff are super friendly. It's expensive - $60 for 6 cheeses!! But it's worth it for a date night, businessmeeting or nice addition to cocktail night. Read more
Great cheese and accompaniments! The pairings with the cheese ranged from sweet to savory with many unique combinations that... worked wonderfully together. A great place to grab a glass of wine and chat with a friend. Great ambiance. Make a reservationto get ideal seating. Outdoor seating is cute but probably better for warmer weather. Read more
I found my favorite wine at Casellula one year ago, and have been a wine connoisseur since. The staff is extremely friendly.... The fromagere’s cheese pairings are impeccable. Great spot for a wine & cheese date night. Oh, their butterscotch cremebrûlée’s pretty delicious! Read more