Reviews for Amata in New York, NY
Came here with my Italian American in-laws who grew up eating good Italian food. I'd made the reservation and would have borne... the blame for a bad meal — but I had nothing to worry about. All seven of us had different meals and all were excellent.Well-prepared food as described in other reviews, great wine list, comfortable, quiet space, and attentive service. Lookingforward to returning! Note: Finally returned after three years and enjoyed another wonderful evening at Amata. Highlyrecommended! Read more
Food is still delicious. Servers are the best. And the owner is always present. And they will accommodate U if you wish a... different sauce if they have it in stock. Great Italian food. Quality is great! Delicious fish! Read more
Absolutely gorgeous meal. 7 of us and everybody said the same stunning food and amazing service couldn’t do enough for us.... Highly recommend. Read more
Lovely neighborhood Italian spot! Very genuine food, not Americanized, wonderful dining experience and the food is superb.
This is a friend’s neighborhood favorite, I thought it was OK, maybe a cut above basic red sauce Italian but with prices like... they have two Michelin stars. Service was a little spotty, food was competent… Read more
Great food & Excellent service..???? Ordered the Risotto with mushroom and it tasted great. Will definitely go back to dine... again..Eggplant parmigiana was pretty good too.. Read more
Came here for a company dinner. Got the salmon and soup. The complimentary bread with olive oil was delicious. The servers were... very attentive Read more
The guys working here are the best and it is much more Italian-esque than most places around here. If only the food stuck more... to tradition and had the "less is more" type of simplicity. The food itself was great, but they overdo it by adding extra thingsthat shouldn't go on already good food. (ie The mozzarella and salad on top of the veal milanese.) I really wish only the bestfor this restaurant and hope they can turn it around. It would be amazing to have a true Italian establishment around here. Read more