Reviews for Brother's Seafood in New Rochelle, NY
I ordered the Whiting combo with potato salad, Cajun fries, and the Shrimp Mac and cheese! Just say this, I have been in the... bathroom since 5am this morning. The fish and shrimp tasted old and rubbery. The fries were not good at all. The shrimp Mac andcheese was the worst I?ve ever tasted. To make things worse the two young ladies working there didn?t use gloves to prepare thefood. The young lady in the front would take orders then go to the back, without washing her hands; went straight to handlingthe food preparation with the other female cook. Not a good look! A serve safe food handling course is a must for the woman. Iwill not be going back and I will not be recommending this food establishment to anyone. Read more
I really hope to increase this rating in a little while because I've ordered here a few times now and was excited to have a new... spot in the area. The food itself its fine, considering the limited options in new Rochelle. My main concern is with their waittime. 3 times in a row the person I speak with when ordering tells me an inaccurate wait/arrival time. Today the wait wasalmost 3 times the 15 minutes they quoted. No on provided an update on the food unless i asked. I do only see two people workingwhich is understandable but please be transparent about the wait and a little more courteous while people wait. Willing to tryagain...Thanks! Read more
Worth the wait! I was pretty annoyed to have waited over an hour for my food but the food wad so good it made up for it. I would... recommend ordering ahead if you're hangry lol. Read more
The food is freaking awesome. Way better than that other seafood place up the block from it
Amazing! Best seafood in New York. The fried fish is so tasty. I try to eat here once a week. You won't regret.
Well seasoned food with great service on the side.This place restored my faith in quality soul food restaurants. My first time... visiting...and the portions and taste were satisfying. I will be sure to return and I encourage you to give Brothers Seafood atry! Read more
We had Catfish with Cajun fries, Whiting with Cajun Fries, Sweet Chili Salmon with rice, grill shrimp and broccoli. Everything... was delicious. I highly recommend it. Read more
I ordered the seafood combo with fried lobster tail and shrimp with fries. The food was delicious, if you want fried seafood but... dont live near city island this is the next best thing. I would definitely order again. Only reason i didnt give it 5 stars, wasthe portions are a bit small but still worth it especially for the price. Read more