Reviews for A No. 1 Pizza in New Rochelle, NY
Great salads, calzones, and cheesecakes. I stopped buying from here they mess up my order all the time even when they write it... down. Read more
I missed their chicken parm pizza since moving away. Had it last week and remembered how great it was in the late 90s, early... 2000s! They moved across the street but same great taste. Will absolutely be back. Also love they still give you 4 free garlicknots with any pie. What a treat! Read more
The pizza is good but the customer service is not!! The older Spanish guy with the colored hair/blonde ontop is rude!! He... doesn't say hello at all. I ordered a salad and when it was made I told him it smelled good his response was "it is good" thatwas the wrong response! He should've said thank you. The 2nd time I ordered he took other ppl ahead of me eventhough I was there1st and he kept me waiting. He did the same thing yesterday when I ordered a slice. 2 ppl walked in after me and ordered andthey both were setved before me and left with their food while I was still waiting. I asked him where's my slice others thatcame after me got their food. He didn't answer and went in back and got it off the counter he had taken my slice out the ovenbut left in sitting on the counter SMH while he got the other ppl that ordered after me food together. Smh His customer serviceskills is for the birds!!! There's other pizza places ppl can go to! Ppl coming there gives him a job and keeps him in businessso he needs to be nice to all of his customers! I wont be back so he lost this customer! More than once I experienced hisrudeness and that was enough for me! I hope he sees this review! TAKE HEED!! if so! Rudeness and cockyness isn't good customerservice!! Idc how good the pizza is. His attitude is poor! Read more
The calzone isn?t even cooked not the first time and the large pie of pizza isn't even cooked fully like really you guys need to... stop rushing cooking food seriously Read more
not so italian pizza, but it's more american pizza
I was reading through the reviews and most are negative. I have ordered from them before, the pizza is average, I have had... better. I ordered the Special available for Mon, Wed, and friday today. Tried the potato skins and they were good. Over all theyare a bit expensive for the quality of pizza they provide . Also, sometimes when I call a rude woman takes our order. Today shedid not take my order but she mostly is the one that answers. Not sure how I feel about this place. Read more
I'm absolutely disgusted. I ordered from this establishment for the first time and I regret not looking into the reviews before... making that call. I found hair inside of my Shrimps. The pizza with extra cheese was an old slice with fresh mozzarella. Thebeef patty was soggy and flattened to one side. In addition to all of these horrible findings, my zeppoli was in a dirty brownpaper bag tossed in Filth. The only thing that was good was the Ginger ale because it wasn't cooked by them and it might help mynausea. Please don't waste your hard earned money on a business that doesn't take pride in food management. I would have takenpictures but I got so upset after a sour stomach I tossed it in the garbage prior to leaving this review. Read more
the food has no flavor, the little bit of sauce doesn?t stick to the plain noodles- i don?t think there was even a little bit of... salt on my food, so bland Read more