Reviews for Anthony's Italian Restaurant in New Port Richey, FL

We used to order from Anthony's bi weekly but oh my I don't know what's going on it's just not as good at all anymore I'm so... sad! We ordered again tonight and I wish we wouldn't have it was all so cold! And our garlic knots are still doughy! The last 2times we ordered everything was burnt :( I knew we shouldn't have ordered again but I had high hopes! It's extremelydisappointing tonight because we had such a long day and we all were so excited to eat! They gave us the option of bringing itall back and having it remade or give us 15 dollars back which was nice I'm just sad that the consistency of bad food iscontinuing I don't think we will be ordering again unfortunately :( Read more

Could have been a 5...and I am being generous with a 4. Food is exceptional but the service is so very lacking. We had a... birthday party for my 14 year old grandson with a reservation. There were 15 of us. There was only about 2 other tables when wegot there, and only about 3 others came in while we were there. Everything was slow getting to the table, from drinks to breadto entrees. When we were done the server was only concerned with getting us our checks, even though we had a birthday cake toenjoy. Absolutely no plates were cleared from our table to make room for the cake. We had our own plates for it and I got up andasked for forks..she said when she was done getting the checks out. I told her were having cake first anyways so can I pleasejust get the forks.. nope, didn't happen. I should have taken a picture of the disgusting table because you really wouldn'tbelieve it. We had to clear our plates ourselves to the other table that our cake was already on..we didn't put them on a cleantable, but she did not lift a finger to clear ours. I was very shocked at the lack of service. I am a server myself and wouldhave done everything I could to make sure my customers were serviced. I actually would have offered to serve the cake or atleast help. I guess that's just me. I guess since the gratuities were included in the checks she knew she was getting paidanyway that it really didn't matter. Read more

I got pizza to go, I didn?t like it. The crust is just like what you get with a frozen pizza. Also our pizza had very little... cheese & only in a few places. It smelled funny almost like plastic.??????????? So we are never going back to try anything else. Read more

First time there on Friday night. My impressions were that the place was very clean and welcoming. Menu was typical but a tad... expensive for a strip mall place. Salad was ok (ROH) fresh. Italian wedding soup was good sized bowl and served hot. OrderedEggplant Rollatini and Eggplant parmesan diners. While waiting another waitress walked by with pipping hot dishes for the boothin front of us. Our food came out warm at best and cooled quickly as we ate. Didn't complain because they would have just stuckit in a microwave. Our waitress was busy and just didn't get our good to us a a timely manner. Food was good and you won't leavehungry. Ordered a piece of Tiramisu for $6.95 and was shocked how small it was, smallest I've eve received. Asked for a takeoutmenu and its an advertising menu with no menu items listed or prices. A joke. Will not be returning. Read more

Anthonys has the BEST garlic knots! We also really enjoy the Basilico pasta dish. Lots of vegan/vegetarian options!

We went to dinner with friends a Anthony?s Italian Restaurant on 6/23/2022. We had a lovely dinner the server was great and she... went above and beyond boxing our leftovers. The next day I heated my leftovers which was stuffed eggplant and sausage withmarinara sauce. As I was eating the sausage, As I bit down on the sausage there was a crunch. I pulled out black hard crushedmaterial. I thought it was some of the edges of the black edges of the eggplant. So I took another bite and the same thing butonly larger pieces. They were black on one side and iridescent in color. I called the restaurant to let them know what I foundso they could make sure they weren?t serving the sausage before they examined first. The lady I spoke was either the manager orowner said, they weren?t responsible for the food once it left the restaurant. I told her I wasn?t looking for a free meal or Iwasn?t going to sue them I just wanted to let them know what was in the sausage. She said they didn?t make the sausage theybought for a local company. I said that doesn?t matter you should be concerned for your customers health. You know if the glasscut them they could sue you. She said they weren?t responsible for the sausage because they bought it from someone else. I toldher whatever, I?ve warned her and hung up. That lady was on the defensive and was so rude. So all that being said she not onlylost us as a customer but we have warned all our friends not to go to this restaurant. Read more

Awful watery Margherita pizza. Not sure why a slicer type tomato was used on this. Should definitely be using Romas. Don?t worry... though, as I anticipated this watery mess would come, and I fixed it. Guys cmon please use better quality tomatoes. I roastedand seasoned mine. Used Flavorgods Pizza seasoning and light sugar on them. I showed photos of the original pizza. The liquid Ihad to dab off, and the end result with the bad tomatoes off and good tomatoes on. Bumped it up to 2 stars because the crust isactually fantastic...Really great pizza crust of all things. I'll give you guys another shot down the road I think. Differentpizza though. Read more

This pizzeria restaurant has a nice NYC vibe and I appreciate the tribute to the Twin Towers! The Sicilian Deluxe I think it?s... called with all the meat to satisfy the pickiest of eaters was my choice and a traditional pepperoni for the kids and a chickenparmigiana hero for the Mrs, we were all very impressed and pleased! I recommend this place! Read more