Reviews for Maggoo's Pizza, Pasta & More in New Philadelphia, OH

Very good food. Place was busy. Would enjoy the outdoor patio if it was warmer.

Slow service overall. They offer a gluten free pasta, but cooks apparently aren't trained on how to cook it and it was served... hard and half cooked. Weirdly, the gluten free pasta is served with a gluten-containing meatball .... with no meat sauceoption. I ordered a vegetable since I couldn't eat the meatball and the server forgot to bring it. Between sending back thepasta to complete cooking and waiting for forgotten broccoli... it was pretty much a disappointing expensive meal. The salad ,which doesn't come with a dinner and costs extra, was ok. Read more

Excellent as usual, I had the "Larry's" salad and pizza delicious.

This place is amazing. It's comfortable, reasonably priced, and the food!! O.M.G. you will not regret trying this place. Whether... you are dressed up fancy for a night at the orchestra or casual in jeans and sneakers you will feel at home. The service isOUTSTANDING- Ask for Jamie.....she's the BEST! She made our first time there an absolute joy and took amazing care of us! Read more

We love MaGgoo?s pizza and salad and get it once a week. Today we ordered thru Door Dash as usual and when it came we were so... disappointed about our pizza, it was so tough you could hardly chew it. The salad was the same great salad as always. I hopenext week it will be better. Read more

We stopped for an early dinner. The special was reasonably priced and good. I had the spaghetti and meatballs with garlic bread.... The meatballs were quite good and the sauce was not too sweet as many are. The garlic bread was delicious. I ordered the bananacake for the first time. Very yummy. Our wait staff was friendly and gave us great service. A very nice locally run informalItalian restaurant. Read more

Very friendly nice place to eat. It's a great place to dine in out get a drink indoors or out.

Check out the food: salad w/their own dressing, loaded homemade chips, small pepperoni pizza, baked spaghetti w/meatball and... lasagna!! They make their own spaghetti sauce and desserts of which we were too stuffed to try. But, hey, we'll try them nexttime! Cause we're going back!! Attentive and friendly staff too. Read more