Reviews for Plaza Diner in New Paltz, NY
With so few breakfast joints in New Paltz I had hope. I mean come on, this place had been here forever. Guess I know what we... don't eat here. Mediocre food at best, with higher than expected prices. If I wanted 16$ a dish I would expect it to be actuallybe tasty. The breakfast potatoes legit had no seasoning, and were slightly soggy. Coffee was terrible and burnt, but I didntexpected much, to be honest. They did not have any non dairy milk, and we were looked at like we had 5 eyes when we asked forit. Old school diner feel atmosphere. The floors were gross. Under our booth was what felt like sand, and walking around thefloors were so sticky. However the bathrooms were fairly clean! Hey, the server was very nice, so there is that. Read more
Paid 16$ for a flavorless meatball on toast and about 16 fries. I think they split one order of fries between us. Took about 45... minutes for me and a friend who ordered the same thing, to get our "snack". Cons: Slowservice Overpriced Flavorless Disrespectfully small amount of food. Dirty No pros. Read more
A charade of a Greek diner - more like a Greek tragedy. Our meal was borderline garbage, and the prices were bloated. $3 cup of... coffee?! Gave two stars because server was super sweet. Read more
We stopped here while traveling. Not far at all from I-87. Plenty of parking. Nice big diner. Clean with very friendly staff.... Even those working in the kitchen. Food was very good and priced fairly. Would love to go back. 4 hours away from where we liveand still we have talked about taking a day trip to the area just so we can visit this diner again. Read more
The food was fine but we had to wait an hour for our check. The waitress brought the chocolate milk she had forgotten at the end... of that hour! We won't come back. Read more
Stopped here for a quick bite, and was we hadn?t. Prices were ridiculous. $8 for rice pudding, $10 for a slice of pie, not a la... mode, just pie! Ordered 4 waters, a cup of soup, a bowl of soup, fries, and potato skins. $45, and the soups were the worstdiner soups we?ve ever had. Potato skins were bland, and fries tasted like old fryer oil. Waitress was friendly, and raved aboutthe soups, which is why we ordered them. Never again! Read more
The food and decor here is average while the service was excellent. Had a Santa Fe salad that seemed to have fresh lettuce,... fresh apples, fresh almonds, but the vinaigrette tasted a bit off. The waitress was attentive and knowledgeable and delivered myfood quickly. Only a year because it is next to the Tesla supercharger. Read more
I'm going to say that this diner was built in the 1960's and hasn't been updated since. I ordered a chicken Souvlaki, platter,... and pretty much it was tasteless. The chicken was some kind of chopped up breaded chicken patty. The fries that I got with itwere so over cooked I could have used them as nails. :-( It is located in the Stop and Shop Plaza in New Paltz. There is ampleparking. Read more