Reviews for P&G’s in New Paltz, NY
Waited 1 hour for our food. Server never stopped by table after we ordered our food. We had to get up and ask two people before... one person finally asked the kitchen about our food. They said it would be another 20 minutes for our food. We ordered fries asan appetizer and not even those could be brought out sooner. Never had such bad service. Read more
Very famous and busy place. Nice and quick service, good food
Awesome lunch, great Seafood Salad and Beggie options. Promt and Friendly service...
We love it here. Service is usually very good. But the food is so yummy. You must stop by and enjoy a nice meal at a great... price. Read more
The food at P&G's is so good, especially the burgers. The waitresses and bartenders are nice, and I think it's better to dine in... before the late evening. I have no words to describe something, but all I can say is that P&G's got me satisfied as a customeralready. Read more
We came across this New Paltz institution on the main street looking for sandwich take out to bring to our walk in Minnewaska... state park. Lots of options on the sandwich section alone. The portion is filling and made even more with a side included.Although the onion rings were kinda over fried, overall it doesnt disappoint. Read more
Up in New Paltz again for my daughter's volleyball tournament. We always stop here for dinner when in the area. However. .it... was a Friday night. It's a college town. They do Happy Hour. There was a live DJ playing oldies...and we loved it, but it wasVERY LOUD!! Also...the food was not quite as good as usual...but still good. Hopefully next time we go we'll not be anotherFriday... Read more
A classic New Paltz restaurant serving up standard pub fare. Visited in October of 2022 and was amazed to see their prices are... still very reasonable, with many sandwiches under $13. Portions are large and food is tasty. Service was friendly and quick. Great to see this place survive the pandemic and still doing well. Read more