Loading

Reviews for Bourbon Mill in New Oxford, PA

Matt Bitner 1 year ago
5

It seems like it would be a great place when its a warm day, but we stopped in after the temperature had dropped and were not... disappointed. We had the big easy, fish and chips, french onion and chicken tenders. They were all good but the clear winnerswere the big easy and the French onion. The burger was cooked perfectly and tasted great. The brisket in the French onion wasdelicious. I really liked the atmosphere as well with the vaulted ceiling. Read more

Sooper Dave 2 years ago
5

Best restaurant on this planet. Period. Go there. You will not regret it. I will be making a special trip back just to eat... there. Read more

sara astheimer 2 years ago
5

Passing through on a Sunday evening, and looking for something open to eat, and we came across this place. The alfredo was... amazing, and hubby really liked the beef tips. Crab pretzel appetizer came out after our dinner, but was delicious and will besnack tomorrow. Employees were all very friendly, food was priced very reasonable, and we were in and out within about halfhour. We will definitely return! Read more

Tanisha J 2 years ago
5

Enjoyed ribs! They were fall-off the bone for a reasonable price. Sat with friends on the back patio for lunch. Was very... relaxing. There's a fan to help keep you cool. Waiter was very friendly and attentive. Will be returning. Read more

Amanda Garner 2 years ago
1

Disgusting! My beef tips and gravy, see picture, looked like dog food. It smelled terrible, and the potatoes had no taste. I... could not bring myself to eat the meat pieces. We ordered the crab pretzel appetizer and it was a very heavy mayonnaise base.The couple pieces of crab meat we had were accompanied by shells. What a horrible experience and waste of money. Read more

Paul Peters 2 years ago
5

It was great finding this place! Food was delicious,plentiful and reasonably priced! Service, staff friendly and helpful. We... were quickly seated and server was friendly and quick with drinks and food! Rustic atmosphere which everyone enjoyed! Read more

Justin Martin 2 years ago
5

Prices on website designated by Google do not reflect the prices of the restaurant. It should be only 1 $ sign. Dude was very... affordable and tasted good. I would recommend it for anybody looking for a quick bite at a low cost. Read more

Melissa Hans 3 years ago
5

This place is beyond perfect! Our server Taylor is the best. I love the atmosphere, food, music. Everything can't wait to come... back ???????????? Read more