Reviews for Italian Fiesta Pizzeria in New Lenox, IL

We make sure we stop here before we return to AZ everytime!! I love the edges what do you love!! So crispy n good!!

Been going to Italian Fiesta for too many years to count. All the way back to the days when I lived in Dolton. They definitely... make a great pizza. Very thin crust with quality mozzarella and sausage. Their sauce is very old school nothing sweet about itand perfect for this pizza. So if you're looking for a traditional Pizza give Italian Fiesta try. Keep up the great work! Read more

1st time ever for "Chicago tavern style pizza"...wanted to try it for a couple of years...no disappointment here...different... interesting and awesome crust...very flavorful sauce...abundant cheese and delicious Italian sausage...we will definitelyreturn...looking forward to trying other varieties Read more

One of the few open for lunch. First time here. Ordered 14" sausage thin crust. Had high expectations based on submitted... photos. Got in the car and opened the box to see something that looked like a pizza only to be skimped to death. All for thenot so low price of 22$. It tasted OK but highly disappointed. No value here. Caveat emptor ! Read more

I drive 30+ minutes just to get this pizza. It's the best. If you like pizza with flavor this is the place to go.

Chloe is the best delivery driver at Italian fiesta! We love her and we love when she brings us our pizza. She?s always fast and... the pizza comes hot. Chloe is amazing. Read more

Veryyyy dissapointed!! I was soooo excited to order takeout from my favorite pizza place growing up, but I was sorely... disappointed. I just moved back to my hometown area after years of being away and my first pizza order had to be Italian Fiesta.Unfortunately, when I picked up my pizza and got home, I opened the box to a horrific surprise, it looked like they poorlyrolled out the pizza or someone cut off the right side of the pizza. This was soo disappointing and just felt gipped out on whatcould have been a long awaited missed meal. Very sad and disappointed. Read more

Since discovering that this is the very same pizza I have come to know and love since childhood, it has exceeded my expectations... every time! From the taste to great customer service, to the time and orderly on time. Has become almost a weekly fixture in myhome! Read more