Reviews for Eddie's Pizza in New Hyde Park, NY
The food was surprisingly disappointing. I ordered fountain ginger ale and it had an after-taste. Eddie's offered no can sodas.... The wings and pepperoni pie were okay but not great. Sorry. Read more
If you like thin crust pizza this is the place to go. They make a great pizza. You could just have it plain. You could put as... many toppings as you want. I got the 10-in pizza with a ton of toppings. It was delicious!. Read more
Solid pizza pie. It's super thin. The prosciutto was a delicious addition, and the staff are super friendly. Definitely coming... back. Read more
Horrible pizza. I got a pie to go about 3 weeks ago. I orded grilled chicken on a large. The chicken was uncooked the bottom of... the pizza was still uncooked there was barley any cheeses. These cheapos put the cheeses in there pockets instead of the pizza.They did not give back my money or make me a new one they disrespected me and I did not even finish a slice and I brang thepizza back to them. Do not ever go eat over there. The lady at the front is disgusting. Old lady. Do not know how to cook. Read more
Everything was delicious. Our waiter Jose was very nice! Pizzas are always top notch and the thin crust is my absolute fav!!
Step back in history and enjoy legendary bar pie . A paper thin cracker crust and delicious toppings. A must visit
Some of the best pizza I?ve ever had! Our party of four ordered one personal ?bar pizza? each and swapped a slice each. Our... server was very friendly. We?ll be back for sure! Read more
Eddie?s an all time classic pizza place and bar. The inside vibes are an old school little pizza joint. And their bar pies are a... must, super thin and crispy and they have really really good wings. And they were featured on the TV Show, Entourage. Read more