Reviews for Altona Supper Club in New Holstein, WI
This place is a gem, the food here is always excellent their buffet is always full and the service is more than willing to go... the extra mile for anything you may want. I live more than a half hour away and frequent this supper club often. I highlysuggest making a stop in New Holstein Wisconsin to experience the food and the camaraderie amongst the locals Read more
Friday Night Buffet was excellent. Great choice of entrees. Salad bar was very good. Our table of 6 had very quick service for... clearing dirty plates and filling water glasses. Read more
We went in a group of 6 people. We got inside and it was really busy and we thought that we might have to wait quite a while but... we were wrong. We waited less than 10 minutes to be seated. All 6 of us had the buffet and had nothing bad to say about it.Overall the food and service was impeccable. I highly recommend! Read more
Went to the Friday buffet for the first time. The salad bar was loaded with fresh choices for salad toppings and many side... selections that were very extensive. This alone was worth the cost. There were 2 soups offered, as well as rolls and softcheeses with various crackers. The main meal offerings were hot, plentiful and most of them were pretty good. Meats and seafoodsoffered at this price, how could you not be pleased and if you left hungry it's your own fault. There aren't many places leftwith so many choices for this value. The waitstaff did their best to keep up with the continuing crowd and were all friendly andas attentive as possible. We will go back to eat here again. Read more
Very nice supper club. Went for the first time this past weekend. Prices extremely reasonable for a Saturday buffet of a variety... of food. Great wait staff. There?s definitely something for everyone. Bathrooms were very clean as well. We will for sure begoing back. Read more
This may be the best seafood buffet I've ever had. Be warned, this place gets PACKED but rest assured that the wait is... definitely worth it. They have quite the amazing variety at an absurdly awesome price. I will most definitely be back to trytheir other buffets! Read more
First, I wish people would refrain from negative reviews during Covid and short staffing, lack of available food items... etc... That said, WOWOWOW! Ate here last night, got twin lobster tails ! Came with potatoes, I chose twice baked, hubby got theseafood buffet. The BEST flavorful potato EVER. Even the fried chicken must be marinated before frying, the actual meat wasloaded with flavor and tender! The coconut shrimp, as good as it gets. The salad bar leaves nothing to be desired, fresh eggs,grated cheese, somehow even the cottage cheese tasted better:) The prices are EXCELLENT for everything you get including thelobster prices. They're smart, they buy in mass bulk, refusing to run out of anything, if possible. The staff and owners areSUPER, super nice and accommodating. It's about a 45 minute drive for us, but that's ok. I actually can't wait to go back! Read more
Well... it's a buffet, and it's priced well. They have a decent line-up, but their food is sub-par. Nothing feels fresh or... homemade, with the exception of their soups which have been good on both visits. We have been for the Seafood buffet on Fridays,mostly fish options, not much going for it. Wouldn't recommend. The Meat Lovers buffet on Saturdays was much better! That roastbeef was the only thing I wanted to eat, but I was happy to do it! The only dessert option is pudding off the salad bar, so thatwas kind of a let down. All in all, it's okay. Maybe a couple standout dishes to eat your money's worth of, but not my favorite. Read more