Reviews for Yoder's Restaurant & Buffet in New Holland, PA
Great place nestled in the Lancaster area! We were originally set on shady maple however that line was about a 1/2 mile long.... Sooooo we decided to so some more site seeing and found Yoders. Food was really good! This place ia definitely on my list to goback. Read more
I want to start by saying that 1: The hostess who greeted and sat us at a booth and our waitress were extremely kind and... professional. The restaurant is clean and pretty quiet considering how big it is. 2: I ordered coffee and it came in a lovelyinsulated carafe (see picture) which held an additional 2 cups of piping hot Java. Only $1.99 for all that coffee and it was anice tasting brew. Those are the 2 reasons that I gave 2 stars. However, the only way I would ever eat at this restaurant againis if they........never mind. There is nothing that they could offer me that would ever get me to come back to this place. Myhubby got the buffet. He said, ?this food is not that good ?. I ordered a bowl of beef with veggies and noodles soup. Don?twaste your time with the soup. The cooks idea of vegetables in the soup was a 1/2 chunk of potato. A can of Campbells is betterthan this bland, brown, water noodle bath. I ordered green beans. They were obviously canned. For the 2nd time only in my life Ispat out restaurant food into my napkin. The 1st time I did that was when I tried jellyfish. Today it was due to the rancid,watery, funky bright yellow colored potato salad I was served. I should have listened to that little voice in my head that waspleading with me not to try it, but I was willing to give it a go. It was in my mouth for approximately 1.5 seconds before Ispat every piece of it into my napkin. When I asked the waitress to take it off the table she asked me if I didn?t like thestyle of potato salad or if there was ?something off with it?. I?m pretty sure when she looked at the potato salad she couldtell by the color and consistency that the answer was ?off?. She did take the potato salad off of the bill, which I did not haveto request. I wish I could take the staff (except the cook) from Yoder?s and give them jobs in a better restaurant. Theirtalents are being wasted. Read more
Fantastic place to eat. Very large dining halls. There are a couple. Plenty of tables, my group was 52. Food was 5he best I've... eaten in a long time. Buffet style. Multiple Multiple food choices, best salad ever. Multiple desserts to choose from.Wonderful staff. Gift shop on premises. Very nice bathrooms. Again, food was SO FANTASTIC!!!! Everyone needs to experiencethis fantastic restaurant, soooooo great. Read more
My family had dinner there tonight and the food was very poor quality. The brisket was extremely tough, The fish dish was little... pieces rather than portions, and there were very little choices and the food was not fresh. The salad at the salad bar was alsobrown. The dessert bar had an old dried out cinnamon bun and basically not much more. Unfortunately none of us enjoyed eatingout at this place. I?m surprised that we had this experience considering that a lot of the reviews were decent. That was not thecase for our party for dinner tonight. Very disappointing. Not recommended Read more
Salad bar great hot foods lots of veg. Ice cream pie cakes self serve. Very good.
Thank you for Hosting Kathy Barnette For U.S. Senate, Conservative Republican Event put on by Citizens Vote. The Food was... Excellent as usually and what a great and warm welcome. Thank you Yoder's! Read more
So if your tired of the big buffet place down the road, try Yoders. Much smaller but I believe better food. They have everything... you can think of and killer deserts. Very friendly people. And if you like, you can order a meal from the menu. Try it.Guarantee you will be back. Lorenzo approved Read more
This is one of the finest places in Lancaster County to eat if you like buffet. Awesome people and great food. I honestly pig... out when I eat here. And the prices are cheaper than Shady Maple. It is well worth the drive. Even the other people who areeating here are nice. And they have a nice gift shop and a great supermarket attached. Read more