Reviews for Sals Pizza And Italian Restaurant in New Holland, PA

Sub-par pizzeria, flavor profile is very simplistic, nothing stands out and makes your taste buds jump for joy. It will do the... trick in a pinch but for the price point I was hoping for much more. On a better note the customer service was very good and theinterior of the restaurant was very tidy. Read more

$10 for a small sub.... ok it alittle expensive but when I receive my cheese steak it was on a roll the size of a hot dog... bun.... bro seriously! It's a shame because there food is decent but a kids size portion for $10 . Come on guys , do better. Either get a bigger bun or drop the price to like 5 bu ks because I got a hotdogs bun Read more

I wanted to leave a wonderful review for the staff of Sal?s Pizza & Italian Restaurant; not only did they go above and beyond... the manager Fabio was wonderful to work with. Placing an order from out of state for catering during a devastating time forloved ones; I went out on a limb and ordered with this restaurant. Not only was I informed that the food was delicious, but theamount of care and compassion that went into taking care of the order made my family and I truly grateful for Fabio and histeam. Thank you to you all; you helped bring a some comfort during a time of mourning . Read more

We have been regular Saturday night customers for cheese steaks for about 16 years now. When the cheese steaks are served hot... they are the best we ever had, however when not served hot they are less than desirable. We have often experienced getting them?not hot? and we have just sucked it up knowing that it will be better next week. And if it was served hot next week then thatassisted in letting us forget about the bad experience. Well, as of now July 9, 2022 it has happened too often, thecircumstances of this Saturday visit has made us change our Saturday restaurant selection. The events included the following;the sandwich was cold, we were charged a price increase even though the menu that we ordered from had not been updated with thenew prices, I used a credit card for the first time ever and they charged me a service charge for using it, I had alwayspreviously used cash and they had never given or offered me their advertised discount for using cash. The combination of the 4things has regretfully changed our mind about Sal?s Pizza being our Saturday night choice. Read more

Foods ok but the guy running the place is a grump. There?s a lot of other pizza places in the area. Step up your game? Plus a... drive up window that is cash only. What?s the point, who carry?s cash anymore. So yeah I recommend somewhere else in the area. Read more

I went with my mom because she said that before it used to be really good. Well it is definitely not good anymore. She got... spaghetti and I decided to get chicken parm with the spaghetti. The portion sizes were so big that they weren?t even appealing,it looked like they put a pound of pasta on our plates. The spaghetti tasted like dishwater, and the chicken parm tasted likefrozen chicken Patty?s. Never going back!! Read more

Perfect flavor, perfect portion size, perfect service and this place should be packed! Ample eat in area, quick to go service as... well , plus they have a drive thru! Plenty of different pizzas, salads, hoagies and subs and more. The value you get isperfect. The flavor of my Buffalo chicken salad was amazing! Easy no frills place, perfect for lunch and dinner. I'll be aregular from now on. ???? Read more

Awesome food, nice people. The best Chicken Parmigiano and delicious variety of pizzas. The slices are so big they fill my... dinner plates.. Save room for a cannoli! Read more