Reviews for Marco Polo Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant in New Haven, CT

The food was good, the price was right, but do not go there if you plan out sitting down and dining in! This is really not a... restaurant just ate to go pizzeria that happens to have tables. We had to beg the server to come over to the table, we had toorder at the counter, and we had to beg for silverware. After the food came out he never came out from behind the counter again. Read more

Place seems clean, staff seems pleasant. I ordered a chicken cutlet sandwich today for $9, but what they served was a school... lunch type chicken patty. The bread was good and the sandwich tasted fine, but if you are selling a chicken cutlet you shouldserve a real cutlet and not a processed patty. Read more

The pizza is to die for and the pastas are amazing. Great portions and so flavorful!! Will definitely be a regular there, can't... wait to try the rest of the menu :) Read more

Do not order from here. Ordered via grubhub and received MOLDY food. My wife tasted a small bit and mentioned it didn't taste... right- upon closer inspection there's mold. We threw away all of the food and I hope we don't end up sick with food poisoning. Read more

Ordered through grubhub food started out delicious. When we got to my dessert. There was mold two splotches of mold in my... tirramizu horrified is not the word. Never again will we order from here if their desserts had mold who know what else went badwe threw out the rest of the pizzas. This place is a no go Read more

If you're looking for a late night slice to grab after the bar this is the spot. Other than that there are plenty better pizza... places in New Haven. But it's not bad. Read more

Simple restaurant, decent food, fair price. I like their pepperoni pizza delivery was always fast.

I stopped at Marco polo to have a quick bite with my wife. We ordered the Calzone and the insalta caprese Salad. It was... delicious and the prices. The shrimp was fresh and the Calzone?s stuffing was amazing. Read more