Reviews for Insomnia Cookies in New Haven, CT
Don?t order on a Saturday night. Took 2 hours to receive my order and the cookies were no longer warm. I called after not... receiving any updates in the first hour. The person who answered the phone was nice at least and apologized for the delay. Butthen it took another hour after the call for the cookies to arrive. Will try a weekday or pickup instead if I order again. Read more
The captain crunch cookie was the special and it needs to be in the regular line up! Love the amount of choices in size and... flavors. The staff was patient while we took several minutes to take it all in! Cookies are cooked to Perfection and are verymoist. Read more
My amazing friend got 5 insomnia cookies and 1 brownie for my birthday. They were delivered with a birthday wish and were still... warm when delivered! So delicious and so large, I only ate half a cookie at a time. Highly recommended. Read more
When you first walk in atleast in my experience you dont feel welcomed the guy taking care of us looked so annoyed to be there... but aside that the cookies are sooooo good. Our faves are the chocolate chip peanut butter and the salted caramel deluxecookies. They are pricey but worth it. Read more
This place is awful!!! I got 2 scoops of ice cream and it looked like a half a scoop total. I said something to the guy but he... could have cared less. I wanted to say keep it i dont want it but my husband made me get it. I don't mind paying $5 for 2scoops of icecream but give 2 scoops dont get the ice cream . Oh and 1 cookie is 2.25 and they are small too! Read more
Driven by a IC crazy time n finally decided to pull up and snag a few dingers. Tried a few flaves and tbh they arent half... bhad....if you cut the sugar in half I would be about em even more. But this place is always open and they got a variety so thattrumps most lol. Def will try others no question haha. Read more
I work at the hospital and we get late night delivery all the time- love their flavors and cookies are always excellent. After a... night out in new haven, it?s also sooo good. Read more
Insomnia is amazing. Customer service amazing. Manager amazing. Employees too. Much lit, fam. 10/10 on fleek, ya feel me? I love... the chocolate chunks Read more