Reviews for Michael T's Italian-American Specialties in New Hartford, NY

Michael Ts is simply the best family owned and operated restaurant in the Greater Utica area. Great food, great staff,... personalized experience from people who know how to treat their guests. Read more

Michael T's Italian American restaurant is a nice place to go get a bite when in town. Now the place is always packed- which is... good, but the food is just okay especially if you're used to excellent Italian food, which in Providence, we are. I wanted toorder the veal parm and I asked server if the veal they used was provimi veal(the best) and she had no idea so that meant I washaving chicken parm instead. So for 3 meals (1 chicken parm, 1 small kids cheese pizza and 1 vodka chicken riggie) and a water, lemonade and Shirley temple our bill totaled $57.00. Not bad, but if you're from our of town keep Mr. T's in your rear- viewmirror. However, our drinks were for free so that's the plus side of things. Read more

Food was good, service excellent. But man, the fish smell in the parking lot could repell you from eating there!

The greens are good. I had the chicken riggies and they were excellent. The rest was just average. Our friend had the Eggplant... and had to send it back as it was cold. It's a bit pricey for the amount you get. Read more

Just came from the farmer's market in Clinton where I ran into Mike. I grabbed a chicken and greens wrap to bring home. This... thing was outstanding and I couldn't go without posting about it. Packed with quality ingredients, very filling with lots offlavor, and borderline healthy to boot! I don't often post or review and I will NEVER publicly post a negative review for anybusiness. That can be very damaging to a hard working owner, been there. If you have issues, address management in person -save social media for praise so everyone can see it! Finally, there might not be a happier person to see than Mike - every timeI see him, he never lets you down - always smiling. (except for some missed free throws during a basketball game - he's nothappy then, they're FREE) Super business, great food, and Mike's service and personality are second to none! Read more

Simply the worst fish fry I I've ever had. It was paper thin and obviously frozen--terrible. I recently took my aunt to Michael... T's and we couldn't believe how bad it was. When you look forward to going out and end up getting bad food, it's just lousy.Probably should have complained, but we couldn't wait to just leave the place. Read more

Maybe we hit them on an "off" night; every place has one. We found the food un-impressive. In fact, the Chicken Supreme was... mushy, and it was clear there was almost to effort put into it - as if it went from freezer to microwave to plate. The waiterwas competent, but completely bored by his job and made no effort at being friendly. Getting ready to pay the bill, I made eyecontact and gestured to him 2-3 times, but he shrugged it off each time. First time there, last time there. Money much betterspent down the road at Cavallos or Carmellas. Read more

We are big fans of this local, family owned eatery, that's been a staple of Seneca Turnpike in New Hartford for years. The... atmosphere is casual and the staff is friendly (our bus girl Alex was particularly pleasant!). They offer generous portions ofItalian/American cuisine, including local favorites like chicken riggies and greens trunfio. The prices are reasonable and theycan accommodate large groups for dinner or a special event . Reservations are recommended. Read more