Reviews for Puempel's Olde Tavern in New Glarus, WI
The food pretty good, but we had to flag someone down to get waited on. It is a cool, old fashioned bar with murals from the... early 1900s and a nice local feel. Read more
Friends and I stopped here for lunch after time spent at the New Glarus Brewery. The friendly staff seated us right away. I had... the smoked turkey sandwich. It was served with just the right amt if lettuce, tomato, and onion so that I could pick it up andbite into it without having the insides fall out and make a mess. Initially, I was given extra napkins at my request, andhappily, they weren't needed. Friends enjoyed/loved the delicious chili in a bread bowl. Great atmosphere and staff. The storyof the dollar bills attached to the ceiling, until they are removed and donated to charity, was interesting and fun. We are fromIllinois and will return on our next visit. Read more
Came here after a New Glarus Brewing tour to have a free beer and lunch. Didn't disappoint. Our California medley soup was... delicious and my chicken salad sandwich was maybe the best I've ever had at a restaurant. Good friendly service. Read more
Great sandwiches and Great cold beer.
Yogi was a wonderful waitress. She told us of several places to visit in New Glarus and Green County. The brats were fantastic.... I loved the cheese curds....and the New Glarus beer. Very neat atmosphere. Read more
This is an interesting bar with beautiful painted wall murals and a unique history. Friendly people. Dog friendly patio (our... waitress even brought a special treat for our pup). Only downfall is a limited food menu. Read more
I am absolutely blown away by the hospitality here! A must-stop in New Glarus. The staff and regulars treated me like family and... went above and beyond to make me feel welcomed. I would drive hours just to drink here again. Bonus: Dog friendly patio ifyou?re driving through with your pup! Read more
Stopped in for lunch, had the BBQ Pork Sandwich, apple slaw,and chips. I was surprised to learn they have no grill or deep... fryer. The menu is somewhat limited,however I learned they get their meat from Hosley's just down the street, and the pulledpork was excellent. So if you like history, beer, and great meat come checkout this very cool bar in New Glarus. Awesome OldPhotos Cover the Walls and the Barback is Glorious. Tell em Polly sent you. ENJOY! Read more