Reviews for Anthony's Italian Restaurant in New Egypt, NJ
Really friendly atmosphere. From the time we walked into the door we were greeted with a smile. The best pizza I've had in a... long time. Lots of pepperoni , nice thick crust. Really great service from everyone in the establishment. Loved it. Gottago back again! Read more
Really bad experience, i order 2 slice with peperoni and meat from the display but the cashier is nice and put my pizza in the... oven but the pizza maker guy take off in only 5 to 10 second and put in my box and put in the counter, really cold pizza, wecouldn't believe it, We didn't have money to buy a complete one so we wanted to share it between my wife, son and I, but I wasso disappointed that I ended up throwing it away and going home, that we had driven from Trenton to distract ourselves a bit. Ido not recommend it Read more
Used to be good, but today marks three deliveries in a row where at least one pizza had a fully blackened bottom crust. They... have to know they?re burnt when they send them out. They just bank on us not complaining. Time to try a new place. Read more
We tried several of their pizzas and the plain cheese is to die for. The broccoli ricotta pizza was pretty good too. The... Margherita pizza had a bit too much cheese. I can?t stop thinking about how good the plain slice was. I could have eaten thewhole pizza myself. Read more
First time ordering. Will definitely be back!!!! So delicious!!! Ordered the Chicken Florentina with Linguine and Chicken... Parmigiana with Ziti. Chicken Florentina was wonderful. The wine sauce gave great flavor. Pasta?.perfect bite! Chicken filledwith Prosciutto, spinach, mozzarella?you can never go wrong. Flavors were amazing!!! Hubby had the Chicken Parmigiana and thesauce was perfect!!! Chicken was tender!! Delicious!!! Food came with bread. Crusty outside and soft inside!! Great portionsizes!! Read more
Very friendly service from the time we walked in till we left. The food was hot and delicious. There was hardly any wait time to... get our food, and they brought it to the table. We are visiting NJ and had to have a white pie. Read more
Coming back from the Winery, we needed to stop to eat something before the ride home. We came across Anthony's and figured we... would stop for a slice. Sure enough we sat down and had a feast. Plate after plate of food our host kept bringing us coursesnonstop. The owners were one of the nicest couple I have ever met. They made the food taste unbelievable. I felt like I was insomeone's home. Take the food what it is and just enjoy the good company. Make sure you try their pasta salad. They make it withhomemade pesto. I defiantly recommend this place with no hesitations. Read more
I used to order Anthony?s a lot but the last couple times they have been so rude over the phone & when I picked up my order... today I felt the girl at the cash register obviously hated her job & was rude. It?s definitely the Last time I ever order fromthem again. Read more