Reviews for Paisanos Pizza in New City, NY
Five star pizza! Regular pie has great flavor and the crust is cooked perfectly! Nice, clean and new location!
No doubt about it, this is a five star pizzeria. They do EVERYTHING right. Sauce is incredible, all ingredients always fresh and... cooked to perfect temperature. Very reasonably-priced and good sized portions. Vinny and team are incredibly friendly. Clean,good vibe, and just great all around. Read more
It can be hard to stand out as a pizza place in NY, but Paisanos has done it. Their tomato sauce is one of the best I've ever... tasted and their crust is incredible. I usually do take out and the staff is always super friendly. I've even picked up dough tomake my own pizza at home and it has never disappointed. Since it's opened, Paisanos has become my go-to pizza place here inRockland. Read more
Absolutely delicious! Super cool menu ; I tried one of their garlic knot sliders (went with the eggplant option) was super happy... with that choice ???????? never saw that on a menu before hope it catches on Read more
Solid Pizza, crust is really good. Driver was friendly and 20 minutes earlier than stated time. Would order again if ever in... the area. Read more
I stopped here with my teen today. I asked why don?t we try this new place, after we had just passed Napolis where we would... usually go. And we were not disappointed! The pizza was delicious. The owner clearly knows what he?s doing, and gives off thatauthentic ?old neighborhood? vibe in a clean, upscale and modern spot. There?s plenty of parking. And we are planning to goback tomorrow to grab a whole pie and try something else on the menu! Read more
An objective review for an online/pick up order: My usual pizza place went on vacation this week so I thought I'd try someplace... new. Paisanos was close and new so I gave it a shot. I ordered through the SLICE app and special considerations like "well donecrust," "lite on garlic butter/oil" for the garlic bread, and "no broccoli, just plain white pie" for their white pie withbroccoli were met (on a side note i'm not sure why they just don't offer a plain white pie?). I browsed through their picturesand saw their pies looked extra greasy/oily but was happy to find upon eating them, that they aren't. (hold a slice up, veryvery minimal grease drips if any) I ordered a specialty white pie with broccoli (minus the broccoli), a plain cheesy pie, extracheesy pie, mozzarella sticks, and garlic bread. There looked to be no difference between my plain cheese pie and my extracheese pie(that i did pay extra for). Upon tasting them, it appears it wasn't extra cheesy at all. The white pie was good butboth the ricotta and the mozzarella tasted very generic (think Polly-o vs Great Value). On our cheese pies they added eitheroregano to the pies after the fact or it might have been incorporated into their sauce. As a result their cheese pies have aVERY heavy oregano flavor (for anyone who doesn't like oregano you may want to call ahead and request they not add it). Of thepeople in my party who had the cheese pies, they agree they tasted "very salty." The marinara sauce that came with themozzarella sticks was SO DELICIOUS and flavorful! The tomato in the marinara spoke for itself without needing the usual ItalianSeasonings to spruce it up. They should consider using that for their pizza sauce. Their mozzarella sticks came in a pack of 6,were THICK, and about 2.5 inches in length. They had more of a beer batter crust on them than breadcrumb crust which wasdelicious in its own right, but the cheese once again tasted generic. The garlic bread was about 10-12 inche Read more
I asked for 3 changes on my ordered pizza : 1- thin crust 2- less cheese 3- extra sauce They did all 3 and the pizza was... delicious. They R now my PIZZA PLACE to go to or order from. Read more