Reviews for Mangino's Pizzeria in New Castle, PA
You want me to share my experience of this establishment? I could have sworn I wrote a review before but maybe somebody deleted... it cause they were salty. This is for the Mahowningtown one. One word could describe my experience at this place. Terrible, Iordered one pizza went to get it with a few drinks and a bag of chips, get to the counter and ask the Gentleman for my pizza, hebegins yelling at me over a receipt. Idk if he was having a bad day at the time but I just wanted my Pizza. You lost me as acustomer then and forever more. Read more
My go to place when I'm nearby even occasionally the hour drive just to purchase items for game days or for the weekend.
People are ALWAYS friendly, and the food is good. The price is a bit high but it's all handmade. And when you want it warmed up,... they put it in the oven and not the microwave. There's also a small deli, cooler with drinks, and goodies rack. Read more
Wonderful food nice people we also bought food and snacks from there to take with us back to Florida ????
Quaint little Italian eatery. Try the DUGOUT. Its basically a half a loaf of homemade Italian bread hollowed out and stuffed... with a meatball sub fillings and the baked in the pizza oven for a couple minutes... Very yummy and filling. Read more
Pizza?s thicker than Donald Trump playing golf. Literally an inch thick. We had the eggplant pizza and it was one of the finest... pizza pies we ever ate. Read more
Mangino's is simply the best pizza I've ever had. It's my long time favorite by a huge margin and I can't think of a higher... compliment. There is just something about the crust, sauce, and cheese that just brings the whole thing together (especiallywith sausage and pepper ring) in a way I don't feel like I ever have. Plus you cannot go wrong with their holiday/party traysfilled with a variety of their foods. Read more
the food is always good. they just need to control the flies in there a little better in the summer.