Reviews for Bill's Sandwich Shop in New Castle, PA
On this trip, I strayed away from my normal of hotdogs with everything plus ketchup and got a gyro instead. It was good, but I... couldn't resist the chilidog smell, so I ended up getting three of them to go. Excellent as usual. Read more
Ordered a Super Sub twice now and the bun is so stale it crumbles as you eat, JIMMY'S never ever had a problem, ordered super... sub double meat and received 2 super sub platters, place has gone into the toilet over the years, go to Jimmys as you arecorrect it's Bill's on State street Read more
Great sandwich shop. Very clean and friendly staff. Great sandwiches at great prices. Stop in and try them out
I'm almost 100% certain there isn't a better hot dog in the United States. Me and my dad used to come here every single Saturday... for lunch. Service is always fast and everyone is friendly. I have never had a bad experience here. 11/10 would recommend Read more
Everytime we get food from Bill's we are very pleased. The hotdogs, chili cheese fries, burgers & onion rings, sandwiches & fish... dinners all taste fresh & DELICIOUS. Bill's has become a Family Favorite to get takeout from. Ps. Anna always makes sure ourorders are perfect & we enjoy talking to her when we see her at the takeout window :) Read more
I decided to give Bill's Sandwich Shop a try and I was impressed. My wife had it when she was a child and didn't care for it. So... we decided to give it a try since I've never had it. We are hooked. I usually get their turkey and cheese sub. It tastes almostlike Jersey Mike's Subs but way cheaper in price. Their fries and rice pudding are good. Read more
This is THE place to go if you're looking for a great hot dog in the area. I've tried many places within a 30 mile radius and... nothing beats Bill's. They have amazing chili, which you can buy in pints or by the gallon; it's a perfect chili, not greasy orspicy. Their fries are also made and are always crispy. Their interior is clean, including the bathrooms. The staff is alwaysfriendly and the prices are cheap. Read more
Terrible service again! They forgot the fries, and the tarter sauce for the fish sandwich. I ordered only 3 things and they... forgot things. I cant eat fish without tater sauce so that was wasted and my kid was very upset that there was no fries. I wontbe ordering from them any more. Read more