Reviews for Brewster's New Buffalo in New Buffalo, MI
Our family decided to have spend a couple of days at New Buffalo, Michigan. We discovered Brewster's which was walking distance... from our hotel. They have really great food, we were there Aug. 11 for lunch. We had cacio e Pepe, kid's pasta and I can'tremember the other pasta dish that we had. Everything was delicious! We love it so much we went back the following day for lunchagain! I had the cacio e Pepe again, sausage and pepper (this a must try!!!). This restaurant is for sure a neighborhood gem! Read more
The food was delicious! The waitress we had was super sweet and very friendly! 3 of us, a bottle of wine, 2 apps, 3 main dishes,... two desserts = $200 total - not bad for a lot of amazing food Read more
I absolutely love Brewster's. The atmosphere is so sweet, inside and out. This past time we went for lunch. We all tried... something new; spinach and artichoke dip (the Flatbread is amazing !!!), Cobb salad, chicken Alfredo and meatballs. For dessertwe tried the lemon cream cake and carrot cake....do not sleep on this carrot cake people. It's heavenly. I can't wait to go backagain. Read more
Hey guys, not sure if it's today or something changed in the kitchen. We ordered bruschetta which was delicious, but I believe... bread still has to be toasted and soft, this time it felt we baiting a rock. Soup was great, no comments here. But I had reallybad experience we chicken Alfredo. When I got I noticed the chicken pieces were huge. Then I took a bite and I felt that chickenis not even cooked properly. I asked to bring me cooked better, I got it new one and still found red spots in chicken meat whichmeans was not properly cooked and also felt that pasta also was cooked fully. Alfredo sauce barely felt the taste. I did orderedthis one last year and had no complaints and I was really happy with this place, I drove here with my girlfriend from Chicago torepeat experience and it was not that what we got it last year. Prices are higher quality is poorer. So I'll give you still fewstars , drinks were good and soup was good. Read more
Fantastic service, delicious food, lovely outdoor patio with enough distance to feel comfortable. We got the special dinner for... two. Great value but more than we could eat. Picked a salad, shared a flat bread pizza appetizer, shared the fantasticmeatballs (4) and spaghetti, finally a choice of cookies and coffee. We got our dessert to go with iced coffee since it was awarm evening and we definitely needed to walk. Brenna was our server with a new person shadowing her. I forgot her name but shehelped make our 45 anniversary dinner enjoyable. Read more
My husband and I sat in the "Glass Room" and had a wonderful dinner. We split the Honeybutter Cornbread($10) for an appetizer,... but enjoyed it so quickly we forgot to get a picture. Then, a Chicken Parmesan($27) and Shrimp&Sausage($28) (minus the sausage)Pasta for our entrees. Dessert was Carrot Cake($8) and Tiramisu($8). Also ordered the Espresso Martini($15) and PerfectDate($11) cocktail. All of the items were perfectly crafted and delicious! The service was also very prompt and friendly.Honestly, with the quality and selection of food and drink, I felt as though we could've been in Chicago with such a meal. Whata gem for New Buffalo! It was our first time here, but not the last! Thank you for the fantastic meal! Read more
Cozy and intimate cafe near the beach, the staff is friendly and attentive, great food and beverages. If you want a romantic... dinner, sit next to the fireplace! You can go for a walk later and enjoy the stars along the beach. :) Read more
It was a beautiful autumn day so we took a drive and had a late lunch at Brewster’s! Never disappoints! Our server, Brandi,... was delightful and fun! The soup and salad combo is a can’t miss meal but the topper was the extraordinary dessert! Warm AppleCobbler! Wow, so good! Read more