Reviews for Thirty Seventh Street Pizzaria in New Bern, NC
Went here to share with a friend what my coworker shared with me. This is an amazing mom and pop pizzeria. The pizza is awesome... makes me want to drive the 35 minutes. Since we were already in New Bern I had to have the in-house experience. It's truly worthevery penny. The waitstaff is friendly and attentive to their customers. Will go a lot more even though I don't live there. Read more
WOW this food was what the Italian call a ?capolavoro? ????The pizza was delicious and I?m pretty sure it had everything in the... kitchen on it. I also had the meatballs and they were definitely made with a real appreciation for the hungry ???? I willdefinitely be returning ???????? Read more
Unfortunately the service was not up to par on our visit. We waited over 30 minutes after we were seated before we were finally... able to stop a server and ask if we could order. We had the two meatball appetizer. It was not served with garlic bread as wasstated on the menu and the meatballs were a little tough. The sauce and cheese were quite delicious though. We had a deep dishpizza for our entree. It was pretty good but quite heavy on the olives. We may give it another try but will get take out. Read more
The establishment was clean ,and the staff were polite and respectful. The food was delicious and made to order so expect a... little wait after ordering! Read more
Place is always busy, but the food and service is also ALWAYS good! Pizza is superb. Wings I could take Or leave. Subs are... actually delicious. The steak and turkey subs were both very good. Love the people who work here too! A+ for this business!!! Read more
The server was very friendly however this is not authentic Italian food. Calzone came precut there was no ricotta cheese but... instead a ton of unmelted mozzarella with a boat load of sauce, it was hard and dried out on top. Their hand tossed pie was morelike a Delgiorno from the freezer. Would not recommend. Read more
I would give it 5 stars since the pizza was pretty good and my wife loved her club sandwich. However, waitress was pretty slow... and never came back by and I found a fly cooked onto my pizza.... Read more
Best Pizza in town. Hands down! The Meat lovers is where it's at. But I've yet to have a bad anything. Service is always great.... Fast, Friendly, and Tasty. I like the dining area where people have signed the walls too. Shows others agree with me. Parkingcan be a little tight, but that's a sign of good food. So I want hold that against them. Cheers. Read more