Reviews for Casey's in New Athens, IL
Got gas for the car and lawn mower.
Ordered a pizza and breadsticks the pizza was soggy and definitely not cooked all the way very disappointed normally very rarely... have problems here but couldn't even eat the pizza and breadsticks tasted like they were dipped in salt Read more
They keep messing up our pizza orders
Pizza was delicious! They were very covid19 conscious & sanitary!
The staff is really friendly, and the dougnuts are fresh. The warm food variety isn't very wide and the quality is steadily... going down. I don't recommend the warm food. Overall, this is just a typical busy gas station with nice people and plenty ofregulars. Read more
Went there before work, place was dead but there was no breakfast food made... Kinda disappointed
Place is awesome I just got lots of beer that I'm not going to drink!
Great staff and fully stocked with my favorite items ????