Reviews for Nicoletto's Italian Kitchen in Nashville, TN

My wife didn't like the bolognese. It was very dry as if no sauce was used at all. I asked for meatballs with my spaghetti w/... bolognese and these meatballs were also without sauce. I've eaten enough Italian to know that sauce is the base of everythingand this whatever they were calling sauce was nonexistent. My wife also had the gnocchi which was mushy and just no really goodand this we have also had enough to know if it was good and it just wasn't at all. Read more

7 stars but I took two off because indoor dining is still unavailable because of the covid boogeyman going into 2023. In all... seriousness, best Italian beef since Jonnies or Al?s in Chicago. Everyone around here thinks a weak, fake French dip is whatpasses for a Chicago beef except Nicoletto?s. Do yourself a favor, get it baptized in drippings!!! This sandwich is god tier.End. Read more

Never again?. We walked up to the window and asked for a menu. They pointed to a stack a few feet away at another window. So we... ordered?..and added a 15% gratuity. While waiting for our food I noticed that the prices on the receipt were about 20-30% higherthan what was on the menu for almost everything we ordered. I politely asked the woman if she wouldn?t mind crediting us backthe difference between the menu prices and what we were actually charged. She said she?d get the manager. He came to the window,not friendly at all?..I explained and asked him the same?.His response was ?We told you what the total was, and you paid it.? Then he walked away. Serious!!! I?ve never once posted a review on a restaurant?..until now. Congratulations. Read more

My wife and I set out to find the best cheesecake in Nashville and after 2 years our search has ended. Nicoletto?s really takes... the cake and their victory is so sweet. Bravo!! Read more

I ordered off of Uber eats... I had spinach fettuccine in walnut pesto with rosemary chicken and mushrooms. Very tasty! I... recommend extra sauce. However the star of the show was really the arugula salad with their lemon dressing. It was so superfresh and honestly, I could drink the dressing. In the past I've had the vegan meatballs and they are also good, overall, highlyrecommend! Read more

30+ minutes wait... From time of ordering from the window to food picked up. Then the food was just warm... Just not what I... expected from $14 pasta joint. All food was just warm, sandwiches and pasta. Taste and ingredients were good.. but if food wasdelivered hot it could've been a great experience. All orders before us waiting also appear to have waited long. Read more

Recently ordered via Uber Eats after I have been eyeing it for a while from the Hillsboro location. I got the Chicago Chopped... Salad and the Chicken Parmesan. The food has good flavor, but the pasta was over cooked and the salad arrived without dressingor the extras I paid for. I couldn?t finish it. While it likely kept cooking during transport, even though I paid for prioritydelivery, I was so, so disappointed. I have a feeling it would likely be better in the restaurant over takeout. Read more

My husband and I order out from here 2-3 times a month. When our relatives come to visit they always request a visit as well.... Our current favorite dish is the Buffalo mac and cheese but we also love the chicken parm and so many combinations of the buildyour own. Ordering online and picking up has always been very easy/reliable and the food is always fresh. The pasta is housemade and you can really taste the difference from box pasta you would make at home - it is better than $25+ dishes I have had atsit down restaurants. I?ve noticed some people complain about the wait or order at the window model in other reviews? I wouldsuggest ordering online in advance and parking in the back to avoid the busy road for the best experience. Read more