Reviews for Pelagos Cafe in Naples, FL

amazing food and amazing value, hidden gem in naples

The food here was Phenomenal. Authentic Greek/Mediterranean cuisine served beautifully with a calm family atmosphere. This place... is absolutely wonderful. I had the classic Gyro and my wife the falafel and the hummus was probably one of the best I've had. Read more

Delicious, Clean, reasonable and the service is great! I have been coming here for years and I have been to other Greek... restaurants? I always wind up back here. I brought friends and family from other states and this is now a go to place when theycome to visit. Read more

Cute, local restaurant operated for several years by the same family. For lunch, the Grilled Vegetable Pita and Chicken Souvla... Pita Sandwich are excellent and the best value in Naples for the quality of the food. Lamb & Rice Dolmades are excellent - bestwe've had. We love the place for take out also. Read more

Definitely the best Mediterranean I've had since living in Naples. I had the Kima (Ground Lamb) Kebab. Excellent flavor, great... char and nice portion. Really fresh ingredients. Definitely recommend starting with a Greek salad before your meal. Wasdelicious. You wont leave here hungry. Staff is very nice too! Will be back soon. Read more

So my hubby and I saw this place on Sat. night driving by. We still had a few errands to run but we were hungry and we have been... longing to find a gyro place like one back home so we decided to come here afterwards. We walk in and instantly we were met withsome tension we were asked if we had a reservation we said no we didnt know we need one the girl curtly said its suggested...btwthe place was dead!!! This was around 6pm. So our waitress comes as we're looking at menu and we had questions about the grilledartichokes and we asked her how fresh are they and this was her answer "it depends on your definition of fresh" and then we askfurther after our jaws are picked up off of the floor are they jarred or canned artichokes and she say "I can certainlyguarantee you they are not from a jar!" These are verbatim comments, guess what they were from a can! So a girl comes by to askus how we are and how is everything and we ask about artichokes because we know that these are jarred or canned artichokes shegoes and finds out for us and sure enough they are canned, you would think that because we weren't eating them we told her theytasted horrible they would've taken them off especially after our waitress Cindi lied to us. But no they didnt even offer! Wellour food comes out and my gyro meat looked like it came from a spam can or frozen I have never seen gyro meat look like this(Iordered the gyro platter) I know gyro meat. My husband ordered the seafood pasta plate...we decided to do halfsies...ya know buytwo entrees and split them in half so both parties can try each dish. So I was NOT impressed with my dish that much and I askedif they had hot sauce...THIS WAS THE ONLY AMAZING THING at this place it reminded us of home and it helped maked the gyro meattaste better...my hubby liked his foodhe only ate about 1/3 of his plate I ate maybe a very small child handful and I wasnt thatimpressed with his either...so we pay we leave...we werent home for about an hour an Read more

Lets talk about the great artwork taking you to Greece. The food is fresh and delicious!! Try everything LAMB! Yes...service... extraordinaire. Read more

The food was outstanding!! We?re never disappointed when coming here!! The chicken kabobs with the olives and grapes and... tomatoes were out of this world! Loved the sweet and salty mix of this dish, with the touch of olive oil on top of white rice!Simply delicious!! Read more