Reviews for Mystic Lobster Roll Co - Naples, Vanderbilt Shoppes in Naples, FL

My husband and I have eaten here shortly after there grand opening. We were attracted to the surf and turf which by the way were... very tasty but we ended up ordering an order of sliders and lobster Mac and cheese because we were still hungry. Yesterday wewent in and decided to order the Mighty rolls that were supposed to be an additional 50% lobster!! That was not the case… itwas the same about of lobster as before with a small half of the lobster claw on top! We were so disappointed and felt robbed!77 for the same amount of lobster!!! We were hungry when we left and went to eat elsewhere!! We won’t be back!! Read more

The restaurant is so clean and polished! That’s the first thing I always look at when entering any restaurant I’m about to... eat in. The service was great. Everyone who works there is so friendly and helpful! Now on to the good stuff…. I ordered theItalian Roll lobster roll and of course I made it a mighty (50% more lobster) it was delicious!! I ordered the combo so I gotsome chips and a water with it as well. PERFECT lunch. The lobster is incredible. Great quality. If you’re looking for asatisfying lobster roll this is the place! Read more

So good! Everything was fresh, and tasted amazing! I ordered the Italian Roll! If I visit Naples again, would likely return

Love lobster so anxious to try mystic lobster. Very lacking in seating comfort and ambience. Lobster in the roll was good but... overall not as good as expected and not attractively presented. Wine available made meal very overpriced. Disappointed. Read more

Good lobster ????. I would have given 5 stars till I got the bill .. and they added a $10 charge for using a debt card .. before... they even knew I was using one … lol … bring cash. … Read more

In my experience with lobster, flavor wasn’t good. The price was absurd I paid $64 for a pound of Lobster and for this two... things I paid $49 with a bottle of lemonade. I don’t know about you. But I think people are abusing with prices. You decided.For high price I don’t recommend this place. Neither for the flavor. Read more

I was excited to try this new place and it did not disappoint! I had to try one of their specialty rolls, The King Louis XIII;... fresh lobster, fresh mozzarella, razor thin prosciutto and truffle aioli. Along with it I had lobster bisque ????. So deliciousand I can\'t wait to get back to try another! Read more

My husband, friend, and I greatly enjoyed our meal at Mystic Lobster Roll Co. We ordered the Maine and two New England rolls.... The quality and flavor of the lobster was excellent. The price was fair for the quantity and quality of the rolls. Rolls werebeautifully buttered and lightly toasted. Samantha, who was taking and delivering orders, was multitasking- always with a smileon her face. Ambience was refreshing; red tables and chairs, fun signage, pleasant bar. I highly suggest ordering a slice of thecalorie-worthy Key Lime pie. We\'ll be back. Read more