Reviews for The Paper Mill Restaurant, Bar & Events in Napanoch, NY

My first time at the paper mill the waitress Tarah was very friendly and attentive. The food came out quickly and was delicious... I had fettuccine Alfredo with crispy chicken and my friend had chicken parmigiana. The espresso martini ???? was amazing. Iwould definitely recommend This place Read more

I had a hibiscus margarita that was sweet and smooth. My meal was one of the best meals I have ever had. Everything was seasoned... to perfection and the steak was tender and juicy!! The service was fantastic, friendly and attentive!! Thank you Jillian foryour awesome attitude, recommendations and service. Read more

As always great food. Can't say the same for our waitress. We were 3 people. 1 ordered a soda, 1 ordered a glass of wine and the... other ordered a fancy cocktail. We were talking and she kept coming back for our food order. Finally after the waitress said shedidn't want us to think she was neglectful. We ordered. Got our food and never saw her again until we were ready to leave. Wewould have all had another drink and dessert. We'll still go back we'll just ask for a different server. Read more

This place was pretty good. Drinks were good, food was alright. The garlic bread looked like it was just a ShopRite roll cut in... half with barely any garlic on it. I got fish and chips which were okay, I probably should've gotten something else so that's myfault but my husband really liked his meal of seared tuna. We got desserts too but I found the key lime pie to have too muchsalt in the crust and my lava cake came with raspberry sauce drizzled on it which I wouldn't have preferred if I had known aboutit but the menu didn't say. Staff was very nice and attentive though. Read more

We came back to The Paper Mill last night to give it a second chance after an unpleasant experience on our first visit a few... months ago (read: sauce being spilled into my purse, hockey puck burger, manager barking at me to move aside while enteringrestaurant), and unfortunately last night did not change our minds. The food was old (brown lettuce, parmesan cracker in thesalad that could break a tooth) or obviously had been sitting under a heat lamp. I ordered the fish and chips and unfortunatelythe cod was so salty it was inedible. The cole slaw was bubbling and had a film on it as if it had been sitting in the fridgeuncovered for some time. I rarely if ever have sent something back but did. There was also a hair in one of our Caesar salads,and also one hanging off the cod (pictured). We love supporting local restaurants in the area and I want this restaurant tosucceed very much, but sadly it will not make it unless they fix the quality of the food they serve. The only reason I am givingtwo stars here instead of one is because since our first visit there, the waitstaff and hostess were very professional (andagain sadly, didn?t seem surprised when I let her know that I couldn?t eat the meal, and did not charge us for the dish). Read more

The ambience was great the food was delicious and the Manager, Waitress and Bartender was very attentive to my party of 5 which... made it an overall great night out dinner experience. We also had the pleasure of meeting the Chef because I raved about thedelicious food and the desserts were bomb my favorite was the cheesecake with raspberry drizzle ???? so good I ordered a secondto take home it was that good. I highly recommend The Paper Mill Restaurant 10 out of 10. Be sure to have the female bartender (I didn?t get her name ) make you a margarita on the rocks delicious I had two they were so good. Read more

My family and I have had our eyes on the Paper Mill on route 209 for quite a while. This past September we were able to get a... chance to enjoy this beautiful restaurant and all it has to offer. First of all the views are gorgeous. The grounds are wellkept and the tent and backyard areas are super cute for a special occasion or event to be organized. The interior is spaciousand large with wood furniture pieces, photos and accents that complement the theme of paper making process. The staff was beyondfriendly and accommodating. Our waitress was super friendly and we had a chance to speak to the manager who checked on usthroughout the dinner to make sure everything was perfect. The menu offered something for everyone from the seafood lover to thepicky kiddos who prefer chicken tenders and fries. My eldest son ordered the bbq wings and raved on how delicious they were. Ihad a chance to sample different dishes from all family members and everything was delicious and fresh. I highly recommend thePaper Mill and certainly will be back but this time hope to enjoy their bar which looks beautiful! Read more

We stopped in for dinner last night for our first time. Our food was delicious. I had the meatloaf and it was very very good. My... family enjoyed their meals as well. I was going to give the restaurant 4 stars but I bumped it up to 5 due to the service wereceived. Our server Lauren was amazing! She was attentive and made our dining experience even better. I will definitely return. Read more