Reviews for Oath Pizza - Nantucket in Nantucket, MA
Crust is indeed tasty and has a nice texture. Other than that, Farmer's Garden pizza was pretty disappointing, pricy, and had us... wishing we ordered from Foggy's. Glad they're moving the ball forward on more humane meat... besides that, not clear what the100% feel good pizza thing is about besides simply repeating Papa John's "Better Ingredients" slogan. Read more
Lamest pizza experience of my life. I'd like to see how this company can defend how a "large" pizza (spoiler alert: its less... than 12 inches and 50% crust), and cheese sticks the size of a saucer are priced at nearly $50 for pickup after tip. Iunderstand that Nantucket is an island but for the same price I could get a lobster roll and maybe even a drink to help numb myprior decisions of wasting my money here. Only reason I put two stars is so that Google's algorithm takes this seriously. Read more
We got a cheese pizza and the works pizza. They really skimped with the cheese on the works pizza, the outer half of the pizza... was mostly empty crust, and the toppings were of middling quality. The crust was unique and flavorful but lacked a crispytexture. Not bad, not great. It?s not a pizza I?d seek out, but if you?re on the wharf and need a quick bite, it works I guess? Read more
We call it fancy pizza place. Pizza taste ok nothing special. Craft made in a 5 min oven just like that. Kids love it. Staff... is always frendly. View is amazing. Place has 4 tables outdoor also multiple benches around on the boat dock where you cansit. We aways do pepperoni and i build my own pizza. Why we call it fancy .... is really pricey for the size of it. Prepared topay $20 up for 12 inch pizza. We go there only as special kids treat. Read more
We ordered a Tuscan Sausage and basil 12 inch pizza that cost $23. The crust was burnt, ricotta cheese was plain and there was a... dark brown sauce (mystery sauce) that either had cider vinegar or some kind of wine or steak/Worcester sauce blend that tastedhorrible! The atmosphere was next to the rest-rooms, behind another restaurant on the wharf hidden beyond the fast ferry gangplank. Folks from Germany and Italy were as disappointed with the food as we were. Staff was very unprofessional wasting mysunset time so he can talk about sports and forgetful because the preparer forgot what he should put on this garbage pizza. Letthis be a lesson! You get what you pay for! Read more
The crust is so crispy and the flavors are amazing! The view from outside while sitting at the picnic tables is gorgeous! I eat... here every time when in Nantucket! I also like that you can order half a pizza if you're not as Hungrey for a whole one! Read more
Right off the boat, you can devour delicious pizza with fresh ingredients here. Nice seating.
This was awful pizza. $81 for pizzas that don?t even have real dough is just a scam flat out. Don?t tell me that it?s high end... ingredients either. Your sausage is processed garbage and pepperoni isn?t thick cut or anything special. One of the worst pizzaexperiences of my life. I?d be ok with the price if you weren?t selling me Boboli pizza shell with mediocre toppings. Whoeverruns/owns this place should be ashamed. I do restaurant consulting and know first hand what quality ingredients are, and youguys do not have them. So stop lying to customers and own up to the fact it is overpriced trash. Read more